#177 - The Myth of Instant College Friends (Dr. Janice McCabe)
Dear Nina: Conversations About FriendshipShow Notes
College is supposed to be the easiest place to make friends—so why do so many students feel lonely, left out, or like they’ve already missed their chance?
In this episode, I talk with Dartmouth Professor of sociology, Dr. Janice McCabe, about why college friendships aren’t nearly as automatic as we’ve been led to believe. We explore the idea of “friendship markets,” how campus structure shapes who becomes friends, and why timing, proximity, and opportunity matter just as much as personality.
This conversation is for parents worried about a kid who came home unhappy, for students who didn’t click with their dorm or first group, and for anyone who’s ever wondered why friendship feels harder than it’s supposed to. If college hasn’t gone the way you hoped socially, this episode offers clarity, relief, and a reminder that you didn’t miss your chance.
Special thank you, as always, to my assistant producer, Rebekah Jacobs!
More from Dear Nina: Conversations About Friendship
How to address hurt feelings, unmet expectations, and changing friendships Have you ever been upset with a friend but decided it would be easier to say nothing? Maybe you're tired of always initiating plans, a friend made a joke that stung, or you sense that a once-close friendship is drifting. Sometimes we avoid these conversations because we don't want to make things awkward. But is staying silent actually helping the friendship? My guest, Jewel Hohman, has spent nearly 6,000 hours coaching people on social anxiety and friendship. She joins me with a practical framework and scripts for deciding when to speak up, when to let something go, and how to have the conversation you've been avoiding.
Are you expecting too much from a friend, or are you accepting too little? When friendship needs don't match, it can be hard to tell the difference between a one-sided friendship and two people who simply have different expectations.
What can you do when your child gets deliberately pushed out of a friend group? Andrea, founder of Strong Mom, Strong Girl, joins me to discuss the difference between ordinary friendship disappointments and targeted exclusion, why parents shouldn't try to fix every social problem, and how our own reactions can make a difficult situation better or worse. We talk about navigating relationships with the other parents, helping kids move forward, and Andrea's powerful reminder that our children can “borrow your peace rather than pick up on your panic.”
Are we too quick to decide a friendship isn’t working? Melissa Radke and I talk about friendship breakups we regretted, jealousy, uneven effort, fear of rejection, friendship “tests,” and the urge to run before giving a friend the chance to respond. Sometimes a friendship can be hard without being wrong.
What does it mean when a friendship gets intense fast, one person always does the reaching out, or a friend treats you differently in a group? Dr. Miriam Kirmayer is back to unpack those gray areas, plus what to do when you’re caught between two friends and how to tell the difference between a friendship pattern and a real shift in the relationship.