I Suck At Jiu Jitsu Show

#370 "Sitting Guard is SOFT" | 951-Hot-Take #2

I Suck At Jiu Jitsu Show

Show Notes

Guard pulling is SOFT… or is it just smarter? In this Hot Takes Hotline episode of the I Suck at Jiu Jitsu Show, we dive straight into one of the most heated debates in jiu jitsu. Is sitting guard weak, or are people just mad they can’t pass it? The episode kicks off with an all-time caller who works a brutal blue collar job and makes a case that might completely flip how you see guard pulling. If you “sit at work,” you don’t get to complain about someone sitting guard. From there, it only gets more unhinged. We get into whether turtle guard is actually a guard or just a bad habit, why people care way too much about medals that don’t matter, and the ongoing gi vs no gi argument about what’s actually “realistic” in a fight. There’s also a hilarious breakdown of people waiting for you to get tired before asking you to roll, and why that mindset might be holding you back more than helping. Some takes are brutally honest, some are completely ridiculous, and a few might actually change how you train. Along the way, we talk about the difference between technique and strength, how rule sets shape your game, and why most people arguing about jiu jitsu online are missing the bigger picture. At the end of the day, this episode proves one thing. Everyone in jiu jitsu has an opinion, and most of them are insane. Drop your hottest take in the comments, call in to 951 HOT TAKE, and if you see someone sitting guard this week… go pass it. ISAJJ Rash Guards: Jiu-Jitsu for Imbeciles, feat. Rob Biernacki(FREE): https://www.bjjmentalmodels.com/isuck Datsusara 10% OFF with Promo Code “ISUCK”: https://www.dsgear.com/ The Competitor’s Journey: https://www.simplifyingjiujitsu.com/comp 0:00 “Guard Pulling is SOFT”… Until This Guy Spoke 8:31 The Truth About Masters Medals (Nobody Admits This) 16:51 Waiting Until I’m Tired to Roll is PATHETIC 22:34 “You Only Won Because You’re Small” 🤡 29:37 Turtle Guard is FAKE… Or Is It? 37:09 “Let’s Roll Light” is the Biggest Lie in BJJ 39:12 Why Instructionals Are So Hard to Follow 43:53 Do Skull Rash Guards Kill Your Cardio? 😂 46:47 Ecological Training vs Drilling (Who’s Right?) 52:55 Signing Up “Unapproved” is SOFT Behavior 59:14 The Worst Guy at Morning Class 💀 1:02:34 No-Gi is NOT More Realistic (Hot Take) 1:14:02 Rubber Guard = Essential Oils of BJJ

More from I Suck At Jiu Jitsu Show

Oct 22, 2026

Women’s BJJ, annoying jiu-jitsu parents, and a cameraman who's undefeated against women and children. What could possibly go wrong? 😂We handed the mic to the jiu-jitsu community for another round of HOT TAKES WANTED, and things got out of hand. From women's-only classes and crazy BJJ parents to Craig Jones vs. Gordon Ryan, nobody was safe.What's YOUR hottest jiu-jitsu take? Drop it in the comments! 🔥Filmed live at the Fuji BJJ World ChampionshipsSubscribe for more of The I Suck at Jiu-Jitsu Show every Thursday!TIMESTAMPS0:00 Kids Are the WORST 😂0:33 Hot Takes Wanted: Day 21:46 If You Hate Guard Pullers, You Suck3:26 A Kid Absolutely ROASTS Her Coach7:50 BJJ Has a Sportsmanship Problem12:50 Eye Pokes Should Be an Instant DQ16:25 Guillotines Are the WORST Submission20:13 BJJ Moms Deserve Medals Too22:27 Podium Promotions Are Stupid25:00 The Dark Side of Hot Takes Wanted29:11 Stop Screaming When You Win!31:38 Should Kids Get Black Belts Before 18?35:17 Jeff HATES Kids (And White Belts)39:28 Undefeated Against Women & Children40:41 Craig Jones Is BETTER Than Gordon Ryan?46:02 The Future of Jiu-Jitsu Is Changing49:31 Are Women's-Only BJJ Classes a MISTAKE?56:44 You're Not a Competition Gym Without Wrestling1:01:26 Why Aren't More Women Training BJJ?1:05:15 Wearing Gi Pants in No-Gi? Expect Grips1:06:35 STOP Coaching Your Opponents1:08:14 Social Media Is RUINING Kids' BJJ1:23:36 Why Don't More Women Own BJJ Gyms?1:26:59 Rolling With Women Is a Lose-Lose?1:29:15 Final Thoughts on Hot Takes Wanted

Oct 15, 2026

We brought HOT TAKES WANTED to the Fuji BJJ World Championships… and one guy told us his Jiu-Jitsu coach tried to steal his girlfriend. 💀

Oct 8, 2026

Spazzy white belts, terrible training partners, and the unwritten rules of jiu-jitsu. Today we're exposing everything upper belts wish white belts knew.Josh McKinney and the ISAJJ crew reacts to YOUR hottest BJJ takes, tells some ridiculous stories, and declares war on white belts (with love, obviously).☎️ Leave your hot take: 951-HOT-TAKEBJJ Mental Models: bjjmentalmodels.com/isuck0:00 Spazzy White Belts Are a Problem8:31 Why BJJ Gyms Don't Teach Wrestling13:30 Ex-White Belts Are the WORST17:34 The Most Controversial Hot Take Yet25:27 The White Belt Competition Problem32:46 The WORST First Jiu-Jitsu Class36:35 Gi vs. No-Gi: The Unwritten Rules41:23 Should Black Belts Fear White Belts?44:31 The Most Annoying Training Partner49:56 The Unspoken Rules of Open Mats52:49 White Belts Need Adult Supervision?56:31 The White Belt Uprising59:23 Can White Belts Refuse to Roll?1:02:08 Our Final Message to White Belts#BJJ #JiuJitsu #WhiteBelt

Oct 1, 2026

Teams, Seasons, and Professionalism: is this the future of pro jiu jitsu?B-Mac(Brandon McCaghren) joins the show to tell the story behind the PGF, how the league grew from an idea into something much bigger, and the moments that convinced him jiu-jitsu could become a real team sport. We talk about building the PGF, the new franchises, Zoltan Bathory offering $100,000 to a winner, and what the future of professional jiu-jitsu could look like.This episode is a playbook on how to build a jiu jitsu brand and use it to change the game!Free Mental Models Course "Jiu Jitsu for imbeciles" : bjjmentalmodels.com/isuck

Sep 24, 2026

Tell me how you REALLY feel.People have said some pretty wild things about me on the internet.So instead of ignoring them, I decided to read them on the podcast.Bad coach. Obnoxious. Mr. Know It All. American Jiu Jitsu is stupid. Apparently I look like Nick Fuentes. We’re going through some of the meanest, funniest and most unhinged comments from the I Suck at Jiu Jitsu community and seeing how accurate they actually are.Leave your own insult in the comments. Maybe you’ll make the next episode.Free Mental Models Course "Jiu Jitsu for imbeciles" : bjjmentalmodels.com/isuck 00:00 Josh is a terrible coach02:53 You guys asked for this episode05:39 “Shrimping primes the nervous system”08:56 Has BJJ gotten boring without Gordon Ryan?17:51 Apparently I’m actually a good coach20:28 The Hot Take Hotline gets weird21:50 “Smoking weed creates cults”27:08 I’m mean to my ukes29:31 Comments from an old competition video33:11 You guys called me out35:10 “This dude is a total nutsack teacher”37:25 Americans will never understand martial arts41:47 Apparently I look like Nick Fuentes44:56 Is Gracie Barra a cult?49:35 “There is no argument for American Jiu Jitsu”50:34 What does AJJ even mean?51:37 The BJJ vs AJJ debate nobody accepted53:59 Finally, a nice comment56:17 “Get to the point”57:28 Maybe I need more gimmicks58:58 Why I actually love your comments1:00:38 I have a list

See all episodes →