Show Notes
In this in-depth episode of Breaking the Rules, we unpack two commonly confused but fundamentally different clinical presentations: moral scrupulosity (OCD) and Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD). While they may look similar on the surface—perfectionism, rigid values, intense guilt—the treatment implications couldn’t be more different. The conversation explores how moral scrupulosity shows up across children, teens, and adults, often hiding beneath “good behaviour,” people-pleasing, over-apologising, and chronic self-monitoring. We also dive into why some clients become stuck in ERP when the underlying issue isn’t OCD at all, but rigidity, control, and ego-syntonic perfectionism associated with OCPD. This episode is especially valuable for clinicians navigating stuckness, treatment resistance, or confusing presentations—and for anyone who has ever felt trapped by the need to be a “good person.” 💬 Key themes: What moral scrupulosity really looks like in OCD Why guilt, confessing, and reassurance-seeking are so sticky How moral scrupulosity differs from OCPD at a structural level Why ERP works for OCD—but often fails for OCPD The role of values, culture, religion, and social media pressure Common compulsions: confessing, rumination, reassurance, over-apologising When rigidity is fear-driven vs personality-based How to treat OCPD using schema, ACT, and DBT-informed approaches What to do when moral scrupulosity and OCPD co-occur 💡 “OCD hijacks your values and turns them against you.” 🧠 “Good people still have messy thoughts.” 💬 “Rigidity isn’t always anxiety—sometimes it’s identity.”
🔖 Chapters 00:00 Introduction and why this topic matters 02:00 What is moral scrupulosity? 05:30 Why it’s common in kids and teens 08:00 Defining OCPD and why it’s often mislabelled as OCD 11:00 Key differences between OCD and OCPD 14:00 Guilt, confessing, and moral pressure in adolescents 17:00 Social media, cancel culture, and moral anxiety 20:00 Common compulsions in moral scrupulosity 22:00 Psychoeducation vs reassurance 24:00 ERP exposures for moral scrupulosity 27:00 Treating OCPD: flexibility over exposure 30:00 When moral scrupulosity and OCPD overlap 33:00 Differential diagnosis, supervision, and formulation 36:00 Clinical honesty and naming rigidity in the room
#OCD #MoralScrupulosity #OCPD #TherapyPodcast #MentalHealthProfessionals #ERP #Perfectionism #ValuesBasedTherapy #ClinicianSupport #BreakingTheRulesPodcast
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from Breaking the Rules: A Clinician's Guide to Treating OCD
This one's for the parents. In this episode of Breaking the Rules, Dr Celin Gelgec and Dr Tori Miller tackle one of the most common questions they hear from families - I think my child might have OCD. Where do I even start?
OCD or Anxiety? It's Not a Black and White Question
ERP is the gold standard for OCD. But what happens when it's not enough on its own? In this episode of Breaking the Rules, Dr Celin Gelgec and Dr Tori Miller explore one of the most important — and least talked about — questions in OCD treatment: when and how to bring in other therapeutic modalities, and how to do it without abandoning the principles that make ERP work. Tori shares what traditional manualized ERP actually looked like in the early days of her career — rate your SUDS, watch the clock, wait for the anxiety to come down — and how the field has shifted since the inhibitory learning model changed the way we think about exposure. Celin reflects on her experience of always working in an integrated way, and why the principles of ACT have always felt like ERP to her — because they are. They also get honest about the moments when ERP becomes a battle. When the exposure menu turns into a war. When a client has every reason in the world not to engage — and what to do instead. Whether you're a clinician looking to expand your toolkit or someone living with OCD who's wondered why their therapist keeps talking about values and mindfulness - this episode will change how you think about what treatment can look like.
Four years in, and we're going back to basics. In this episode of Breaking the Rules, Celin and Tori walk through the full OCD assessment process from the ground up - because with new listeners joining and so much focus on treatment in recent episodes, it felt like the right time to start at the beginning.
When Therapists Spiral Too: What OCD Taught Us About Ourselves