Mary in America

Somebody Has to Pick the Stocks

Mary in America

Summary

Adriana Robertson, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School, challenges the conventional understanding of index funds in a recent discussion. She argues that these funds, often labeled as "passive," are actually shaped by numerous discretionary decisions made by index providers. This revelation stems from her research, culminating in her paper titled "Passive in Name Only, Delegated Management and Index Investing," where she emphasizes that the construction of indices is far from standardized and involves significant choices that investors often overlook.

Robertson explains that index funds were pioneered by Jack Bogle at Vanguard, who aimed to democratize investing by offering low-cost, diversified options for retail investors. While index funds have indeed made investing more accessible, she warns that many investors may not fully grasp the implications of how these funds are managed. The discussion highlights the importance of understanding the underlying mechanics of index investing, especially as the landscape of capital markets evolves with increasing concentration among a few large companies, which can impact overall market dynamics.

The conversation also touches on the role of capital markets in facilitating investment and innovation, suggesting that greater participation in these markets could enhance financial literacy and foster a sense of ownership among everyday investors. Robertson's insights underscore the need for investors to be informed about where their money is going and the decisions that shape their investment outcomes, advocating for a more nuanced view of index funds and their role in the economy.

Show Notes

Adriana Robertson is a law professor at the University of Chicago who, a decade ago, got fixated on index funds. They seemed so important – the best, or maybe only, good investing advice was to put your money in an index fund, right? So, she wondered, what exactly is an index fund? How does one get made? She poked around and couldn’t find research that answered her questions. So unfortunately she had to do it herself. And what she found was that these “passive” investing vehicles aren’t really passive at all. At the end of the day, somebody has to pick the stocks. She joins us to tell us what index funds – and for that matter, capital markets in general – are supposed to be doing, and if they are actually doing it. Further Reading: Adriana Z. Robertson - Passive in Name Only: Delegated Management and “Index” Investing Harry Markowitz - Portfolio Selection Lucian A. Bebchuk - The Case for Increasing Shareholder Power Yueran Ma - What Adam Smith Didn’t Foresee About Capitalism

Subscribe to the show!

YouTube Instagram TikTok Website

More from Mary in America

Oct 22, 2026

When we go to buy something – online, on our phones, in person, doesn't matter – there’s an entire invisible infrastructure behind whatever price we see. Companies have dedicated data scientists who use our zip codes, computer type, browsing history, cursor movements, SO much information, to determine how much they can charge us, how much we are willing to pay. On the consumer side, basically nobody likes it. So how did it get to this, and what can we do about it? In part it’s because our technological capabilities have advanced at a faster rate than our social structures, rules and laws. Stephanie Nguyen was Chief Technologist at the Federal Trade Commission from 2021 to 2025, where she worked on cases against companies who were surveillance-pricing us unfairly. She unpacks how companies are spying on us, when that crosses a line, and what changes we’re starting to see as consumers fight back.

Oct 15, 2026

Critical minerals and rare earths – special rocks – do everything from make our cars go to treat cancer. But the vast majority of production, processing, and manufacturing largely happens in or is controlled by China. For decades, we didn't think that was a problem. Plus, mines were dirty and dangerous and we preferred that they be located elsewhere. But in recent years, as global trade has turned from a tool of diplomacy to a weapon, we and every other country realized that it’s probably suboptimal to cede these literally-critical elements. Mining economist Gracelin Baskaran loves these rocks, and tells us what makes them so important, why the US was so lackadaisical about them, and what we’re doing about it now.

Oct 8, 2026

Over a decade ago, Eric Zwick got assigned an unusual project at the U.S. Treasury: Find out how much tax businesses were paying. But the data was a mess, so Eric and two friends helped comb through it and, in doing so, got to build a topographic map of business activity and profitability in America. And it suddenly revealed a class of people who had been hard to see before: the “everywhere millionaires,” or the “stealthy wealthy.” People who built an amazing amount of wealth selling things like cars, $5 electric toothbrushes, and seamless gutters. He tells us about these everywhere millionaires, the policies that helped them get so rich, and how this revelation helped reshape his understanding of the U.S. Further Reading/Listening Owen Zidar & Eric Zwick - The Everywhere Millionaire Planet Money - My Favorite Tax Loophole

Oct 1, 2026

When novelist Min Jin Lee writes a book, she goes deep. She spends years researching, interviewing relevant people whose experiences and jobs will comprise her characters and plot. In her new book American Hagwon, she threw herself into the intense schooling and education systems, and extracted lessons that are sincerely useful, which she unpacks in this episode, including: a focus on achievement obscures the point of learning; community is how to survive; karma is real, just be patient; and how – unprompted! – it all goes back to bond markets.

Sep 24, 2026

Being a country’s central banker is a technical job. But, just like high school, if you are a popular central banker, it pays off. Aditi Sahasrabuddhe is a political scientist at Brown University, and has researched just how much it pays to be popular. It’s the kind of question that the field of economics largely neglects. Aditi looks at central-bank-likeability through the manifestation of swap lines, currency exchanges made available between two economies. These become especially important in a moment of crisis, and a close connection between central bankers can mean the difference between an economy that sinks and one that swims. Further Reading: Aditi Sahasrabuddhe: Banker’s Trust Liaquat Ahamed: Lords of Finance Financial Times: Swap lines are geopolitical infrastructure Financial Times: A less independent Fed raises risks to a key crisis tool Financial Times: Will the Fed continue to assume its global responsibilities?

See all episodes →