Show Notes
Cory Doctorow is a prolific writer of both fiction and non-fiction. His latest book is Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Went Wrong and What To Do About It. Cory and host Alan Chapell discuss the three stages of enshittification, its root causes, and the underlying social movement that is critical to addressing (and perhaps even reversing) its impact.
Recognizing that they come at this from very different perspectives, Alan and Cory also go deep into some of the endemic challenges of the ads space while wrestling with pro's and con's of data minimization, contextual advertising and how to offer a private right of action to the enforcement of privacy laws. Alan's Substack on CIPA the VPPA and anti-SLAPP laws is at https://chapell.substack.com/p/can-anti-slapp-save-ad-tech-from and should complement the discussion.
Cory's bio is at https://craphound.com/bio/ and you can find out more about his book Enshittification at https://tinyurl.com/y7u698a6.
Takeaways
Enshittification describes how digital platforms decay under monopoly power, shifting value from users to advertisers and then shareholders.
Monopoly and weak regulation allow corporations to capture markets and regulators, eroding user rights and competition.
Loss of interoperability and restrictive IP laws (like the DMCA) prevent users from fixing or improving technology.
Privacy and data exploitation are central to tech monopolies’ power, stronger, simpler rules are needed over complex consent systems.
Behavioral advertising should be replaced by contextual models to reduce surveillance and restore balance for publishers.
Private right of action can help enforce privacy rights when regulators fail.
Global antitrust movements in Europe, Canada, and Asia show more progress than the U.S.
Coalition building across privacy, labor, and antitrust advocates is key to countering corporate concentration.
Chapters00:00 Introduction and Enshittification explained04:20 How monopolies cause platform decay11:15 Market consolidation and regulatory capture13:30 Tech worker power and the loss of interoperability20:25 Key issues, privacy, competition, and IP27:25 Problems with consent-based privacy systems29:45 Case for banning behavioral advertising41:25 Enforcement and the role of private litigation51:00 Antitrust progress and shifting global momentum55:30 Building coalitions to fight tech monopolies
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More from The Monopoly Report
Is Apple's Safari browser becoming another gatekeeper for the open web? Host Alan Chapell sits down with Gene Burrus, competition and regulatory attorney and Global Policy Counsel for the Coalition for App Fairness. Gene and Alan discuss Apple’s App Tracking Transparency framework and the European competition response, the Safari domain block list, Google’s conspicuous absence from Apple’s block list, the role of interoperability as a key component of the growth of the web, and the risk of Apple’s actions leading to a splinternet. They also share a few of the (albeit limited) choices available to the adtech community. The Chapell Regulatory Insider can be found at: https://chapellreport.substack.com/ Gene Burrus may be found at https://burruscompstrategies.com/about Takeaways
Keith Petry, SVP of Data and Identity at Viant, and Scott Messer of Messer Media and host of Ad Tech Therapy join Alan Chapell. They explore Google’s ad tech remedies, publisher economics, industry standards, AI’s impact on content, third-party cookies, measurement, and why stronger collective action may be critical to the future of the open web.
Alan Chapell speaks with Dr. Johnny Ryan, Director of ENFORCE at the Irish Council for Civil Liberties, about GDPR enforcement, real-time bidding, purpose limitation, publisher economics, and the growing power of major technology platforms. Johnny is a long-time critic of programmatic advertising - having characterized real-time bidding as “The biggest data breach in history.” Chapell and Ryan explore whether privacy-friendly advertising can support publishers, the costs of fraud and ad tech intermediaries, and what Europe’s regulatory approach means for the future of digital advertising. The Chapell Regulatory Insider can be found at: https://chapellreport.substack.com/ Takeaways:
Claire Stapleton joins Alan Chapell to discuss her years inside Google, from shaping the company’s internal communications to helping organize the 2018 Google walkout. They explore the following from multiple perspectives: Google’s “Don’t Be Evil” philosophy, employee activism, corporate messaging, the limits of worker dissent, and what Claire calls “PR jujitsu” and what Alan characterizes as “Regulatory jujitsu.” Alan and Claire compare notes as between Google’s approach to addressing internal consent, to the company’s approach to managing dissent within the broader digital media industry and within standards bodies. Drawing heavily from Claire’s book Don't Be Evil: Bad Bosses, Fake Promises, and My Escape from Big Tech.the conversation also examines how money, power, and institutional influence can reshape corporate values, plus why employees should build an identity and sense of purpose beyond their jobs. Don’t Be Evil by Claire Stapleton can be purchased at https://tinyurl.com/5n7kkhv3.Yield by Ari Paparo can be purchased at https://tinyurl.com/msfdwrry. The Chapell Regulatory Insider can be found at: https://chapellreport.substack.com/ Takeaways:
Marc Guldimann, founder and CEO of Adelaide, joins Alan Chapell to discuss why attribution may be solving the wrong problem, how AU measures media quality, and whether attention can become a true currency for digital advertising. The Chapell Regulatory Insider can be found at: https://chapellreport.substack.com/ Takeaways