
#154 How Political Extremes Shape Customer Loyalty and Brand Evangelism
The Trusted Guide Podcast with Mark SlatinShow Notes
What drives customers to cling fiercely to a brand, even when it means paying more or overlooking problems others wouldn't forgive? Is our political identity quietly fueling a new kind of "super loyalty" that's transforming customer behavior, for better or worse? In this episode of the Delighted Customers podcast, I dive into these burning questions with my returning guest, Dr. Forrest Morgeson, associate professor, researcher, and interim chairperson of the Marketing Department at Michigan State University's Eli Broad College of Business. Forrest, drawing on a unique blend of academic rigor and industry insight, explores how political polarization isn't just shaping national conversations—it's shaping the way brands connect with customers, and how those customers, in turn, connect back. If you're in marketing, customer experience, or simply care about understanding what really makes customers tick in today's politically charged climate, this episode is for you. Forrest's background with the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), along with his extensive research on brand loyalty and the nuances of political extremism, make him a must-listen expert. He's not just sharing theories—he's revealing data-driven insights you can act on, whether you're a CX leader or a curious consumer. Here are three essential questions Forrest answers on the show: What is the surprising link between political extremism and "super loyalty" to brands, and how does this affect both customers and companies?
Why do politically extreme customers sometimes become brand evangelists—defending their favorite brands even after service failures or price hikes?
What practical ethical and strategic lessons should business leaders take away when targeting or retaining highly loyal customer segments in a polarized marketplace?
Don't miss this timely, thought-provoking conversation—listen now and subscribe so you never miss an episode. Find Delighted Customers on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, or wherever you download your favorite podcasts! Meet Forrest Morgeson Forrest Morgeson, Ph.D., is an associate professor of marketing at the Eli Broad College of Business at Michigan State University, where he currently serves as the interim chair of the Marketing Department. With broad expertise spanning marketing strategy, customer satisfaction, and management, Forrest has played a pivotal role as co-director of the doctoral program and is deeply involved in shaping the next generation of business leaders at MSU. He is renowned for his work with the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), where his research examines how consumers evaluate companies, sectors, and even government services over time. Forrest's latest research breaks new ground by investigating the relationship between political identity and customer loyalty, shedding light on how political extremism can create deeply attached, even "defensive," customers. He is a passionate educator, a prolific researcher, and has been published in leading journals on topics ranging from service satisfaction to the psychological underpinnings of loyalty. To learn more or connect with Forrest, visit his faculty page at MSU or connect with him on LinkedIn. Show Notes & References American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI): theacsi.org
Oliver's Framework for Loyalty (referenced work on the stages of customer loyalty): See summary on the four stages
Recent case studies mentioned: Bud Light controversy | Target Pride campaign blowback
Connect with Forrest Morgeson: Michigan State University Bio | LinkedIn
Catch every episode of Delighted Customers on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and all major podcast platforms!
More from The Trusted Guide Podcast with Mark Slatin
Smart leaders. Stalled change. Here's why: most leadership teams say they "support" customer experience — but support isn't the same as action. It's been over a dozen years since "Outside In" was written and Megan Burns shared the six CX disciplines as their working model. I was curious about what has changed since those days - what would she include today that wasn't in the book. In this episode, we dig into why "we need leadership support" is the wrong ask, what actually moves change forward (funding, policy shifts, real decisions), and why that truth exists alongside a harder one: leadership support is genuinely difficult to earn, and change leaders still need a real strategy to get it. We go behind the scenes of the 6 Disciplines customer experience maturity model from Outside In — why it was built on behavior instead of attitude, and which disciplines companies most often fake their way through (customer understanding, governance, and culture top the list). We also unpack engagement strategy: how to find the "power core" inside an organization, build coalitions, and win the small battles that make bigger change possible. And we close with the one question every CX leader should ask before diagnosing any gaps: what are we already doing right? Show Notes 🔗 Episode 41 — How Do We Activate Employees to Deliver Consistently Good, Strategically Amazing Experiences? https://bit.ly/4gUlJWB 📖 Book: Outside In https://amzn.to/4xcilMJ 🔗 Connect with Megan Burns https://www.linkedin.com/in/meganburns/ 🔗 CX Index — Forrester https://www.forrester.com/research/cx-index/ Topics covered: Why "leadership support" is the wrong ask — and what real action looks like The paradox: support is hard to get, but that can't become the excuse for inaction Building an internal engagement strategy: finding the "power core" and building coalitions The origin story of the 6 Disciplines maturity model (built at Forrester, 2010) Why "behavior, not attitude" was the core design principle The 6 disciplines: Strategy, Customer Understanding, Measurement, Design, Governance, Culture Where companies most often perform "superficially" (and think they're excelling) Why leadership and change management were intentionally left out of the original model — and what Megan would do differently today The one diagnostic question to ask before any CX gap analysis
Why Good Ideas Get Blocked: The Trust Equation for Change Leaders with Charlie Green It pairs naturally with the thumbnail, names the recognizable framework, and makes the change-leadership application explicit. WHY GOOD IDEAS GET BLOCKED: THE TRUST EQUATION FOR CHANGE LEADERS WITH CHARLIE GREEN Why do strong ideas—with solid evidence and a compelling business case—still get blocked? Because leading change takes more than credibility, data, and ROI. It requires trust. In this episode, I’m joined by Charlie Green, founder of Trusted Advisor Associates and co-author of the landmark book The Trusted Advisor, to explore how the Trust Equation applies to change leadership. Charlie explains why the framework should really be called the “Trustworthiness Equation” and breaks down its four components: credibility, reliability, intimacy, and self-orientation. We discuss why leaders often overestimate the rational elements of trust and underestimate the power of emotional safety, genuine attention, and making people feel heard. I also share a costly leadership mistake from my banking career: I failed to fully explore one stakeholder’s reservations about a major initiative, and the resulting resistance sent our work sideways for three years. If you lead change without direct authority—or struggle to secure support for ideas you know can make a difference—this conversation will help you approach resistance, influence, and stakeholder relationships differently. IN THIS EPISODE, YOU’LL LEARN: • Why trustworthiness matters more than simply asking others to trust you • How the four components of the Trust Equation work • Why intimacy and self-orientation can matter more than credentials and reliability • How fear prevents leaders from asking the necessary follow-up question • Why “Tell me more” can transform resistance into collaboration • How to prepare thoroughly while remaining open to other perspectives • What it means to “detach from the outcome” • Why people need to feel heard before they will support change • How an overlooked stakeholder concern can derail an initiative • Why ROI and other rational measures rarely tell the whole story SHOW NOTES :
Most change efforts don't fail because of bad strategy. They fail because the people leading them are asking the wrong question. Seth Godin has written 21 bestselling books. He's built movements, challenged industries, and spent decades studying why some ideas spread and others die quietly in conference rooms. In this conversation, Seth cuts straight to what most change leaders get wrong — and what to do instead. You'll walk away with: A clearer way to think about strategy that actually holds up under pressure Why chasing ROI may be the thing killing your credibility — and what to say instead How storytelling works (and what has to happen after you tell it) What it really takes to lead change when you don't have the authority to force it This one stayed with me long after we recorded it. I think it'll do the same for you. 🎧 This Is Strategy by Seth Godin — linked in the show notes.
What if the real goal of customer experience isn't delivering better experiences at all? In this episode of The Trusted Guide Podcast, Mark Slatin sits down with Joe Pine, co-author of The Experience Economy and one of the most influential thinkers in customer experience and business strategy. Joe argues that we're entering the next stage of economic value creation—one where organizations create value not merely through products, services, or experiences, but by helping people become who they aspire to be. At the heart of this conversation is a powerful idea: transformation requires identity change. Together, Mark and Joe explore what this means for customer experience professionals, business leaders, and anyone responsible for leading change. If customers are ultimately seeking a better version of themselves, how should that change the way we design experiences, build relationships, and measure success? And what can change leaders learn from this insight when trying to influence stakeholders and drive organizational transformation? In this episode, you'll learn: • Why transformation is fundamentally about identity • The difference between experiences and transformations • What organizations miss when they focus only on customer satisfaction • How understanding identity can create deeper customer loyalty and engagement • Why successful change leadership requires helping people become, not just do Whether you're leading customer experience, organizational change, or business transformation, this conversation will challenge you to rethink what people are really seeking—and how leaders can help them get there.