Summary
Three men convicted of raping a woman after luring her from a Dublin nightclub are appealing their convictions. Anthony Hickey, Fabio Vincente, and Matan Zulfagari argue that the trial judge made errors regarding the victim's testimony and jury instructions. They contend that allowing the victim to give evidence behind a screen may have influenced the jury's perception and that the judge's responses to their questions during deliberations were inadequate.
The appeal centers on two main points. First, the defense claims that the jury struggled to understand the difference between "recklessness" and "carelessness" in relation to the rape laws, and the judge's failure to clarify this distinction may have compromised their decision-making. Second, the defense argues that the circumstances justifying the use of a screen for the victim's testimony were not sufficiently established, asserting that her concerns about mental health did not meet the threshold for special treatment in court.
The case, which involved disturbing evidence including video recordings of the assault, highlighted the organized nature of the attack. The victim described being stalked and assaulted by the men, who were later found guilty based on both her testimony and the incriminating videos shared among the accused. The presiding judge has reserved judgment on the appeal, with a decision expected at a later date.
Show Notes
Three men convicted of raping a woman lured from a Dublin nightclub to a car and later brought to a house in South Dublin are appealing their convictions. Anthony Hickey, Fabio Vincente, and Matin Zolfaghari argue that their victim should not have given evidence behind a screen and say the judge erred is his charge to the jury. Nicola speaks with Niall Donald about the case and the grounds of appeal. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from Crime World
The horrors of Ireland’s last witch trial will be brought to life by former State Pathologist Dr Marie Cassidy in a new documentary to be screened over Halloween. Dr Cassidy goes back in time to 1711 when eight women living in the close knit community of Islandmagee were accused of witch-craft, tried, jailed and stoned. Nicola talks with Marie about the fascinating story and the modern investigative skills she brought with her to tell it. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Sharon Lynn and Brian Gallagher both had their lives turned upside down in a second when they lost a brother to separate, violent, unprovoked one-punch attacks. Today, Niall talks to Sharon and Brian about their campaign for changes in sentencing and why they believe we can learn from Australia's Coward Punch initiative. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Veteran criminal John Gilligan is facing more than 11 years in prison for drug and gun charges. An indictment presented to a court in the Costa Blanca heard the 74-year-old was arrested in a villa with ketamine, cocaine and marijuana along with a firearm. Nicola speaks with Niall Donald about the pensioner and what trouble he faces in Spain. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Christa Pike has spent 30 years on Tennessee's death row and last month made international headlines when her execution by lethal injection was botched. Her life is a story of childhood abuse, a brutal murder, and how claims of Satanism led to her conviction. Eamon Dillon speaks to documentary maker Steve Payne, who was part of a crew that interviewed her shortly after she was sentenced to death in 1995. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Gregory Fox, who brutally murdered his wife and two sons has been moved to an open prison as he gets one step closer to freedom. Fox, who is originally from Clondalkin in Dublin, killed his wife Debbie, 30, and sons Trevor, nine, and seven-year-old Killian, in July 2001. It is understood the killer was moved to Shelton Abbey in Co Wicklow this summer as part of his sentence management set out by the Parole Board. Crime World's Caoimhe Young talks to Criminal Justice academic Clare Laxton about Fox and his move to Shelton Abbey. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.