Show Notes
Last week, Christina Buttons told me our culture is "deeply biased against agency." She's right. And once you see it, you can't unsee it.
The left has spent two decades teaching young people that they are prisoners of systemic forces too large to fight. The populist right has spent the last few years teaching the same people that they are victims of a stolen inheritance, robbed by enemies who must be named and
destroyed. The packaging is different. The product is the same — the relief of not being responsible, and the warm, addictive feeling of having someone to blame.
It is poison — for individuals, and for republics.
In this monologue Jeremy gets into what agency actually means, why Tucker
Carlson's recent attack on Ben Shapiro is a perfect window into what the populist right is selling, and why the data on human flourishing — from the Harvard Study of Adult Development to Raj Chetty's mobility
research to Viktor Frankl's observations from the concentration camps — all points the same direction: the belief that your choices matter is one of the strongest predictors of whether your life goes well.
Jeremy also gets into René Girard's scapegoat mechanism, why the rising
antisemitism on both the left and the right has the exact shape Girard predicted, why every revolution premised on perfecting man has produced mass graves, and why Jordan Peterson's most-mocked piece of advice — clean your room — is the operational definition of agency.
And Jeremy tells us what we actually do about it. Marry the right person. Go to church. Serve your community. Work hard. Refuse, every single day, to accept the role of the victim.
The country is you and three hundred million other people who are each doing the same calculation about whether their own life is worth taking responsibility for. If enough of us decide it is, the country gets
fixed.
#Agency #TuckerCarlson #BenShapiro #JordanPeterson #Conservatism
00:00 — Agency: the most unfashionable idea in politics
01:14 — The Harvard Study, Raj Chetty, and the Shapiro–Carlson fight
06:35 — Learned helplessness and Viktor Frankl
09:44 — The left's victimhood and the right's victimhood
12:23 — René Girard, scapegoats, and where the playbook always ends
20:38 — The most important thing Jordan Peterson ever said
23:32 — The victim identity is a transfer of power
27:23 — The 1950s myth and "bad policy isn't an excuse for a bad life"
30:00 — Adam, Eve, and the original denial of agency
31:33 — Six rules to rule the world Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More from The Jeremy Boreing Show
The generic ballot says Democrats by nine. The markets say there's a 90% chance they win. Rod D. Martin says Republicans can still pull it out — and it comes down to about four votes per precinct. With the midterms two weeks away, Jeremy Boreing sits down with early PayPal team member Rod D. Martin, Fixed Point Foundation founder Larry Alex Taunton, and Joel Berry, formerly of The Babylon Bee, to break down the path to winning the House, the fight to hold the evangelical coalition together, and what comes next for Trump, Iran, and the right.
Is Gen Z cooked? Jeremy Boreing doesn't think so, and his three Gen Z guests are a big reason why. On the third anniversary of October 7th, Jeremy sits down with Nevaeh Souza, Jacob Falach, and Josh Carr for a candid conversation about why so many young Americans feel the American dream has slipped out of reach, and what it will take to get it back.
Dallas Jenkins, creator and director of The Chosen, sits down with Jeremy Boreing one week after stepping off the set for the final time — 528 days of production over eight years. The two friends first met in Los Angeles more than a decade ago, before The Chosen or The Daily Wire existed. Now they talk about failure, surrender, ambition, and what it really costs to make art for an audience of millions.
The most advanced, most comfortable civilization in human history is choosing not to have children. The U.S. fertility rate is near 1.6, well under the 2.1 needed to replace a population. South Korea hit 0.72, the lowest ever recorded. Why is this happening, and can it be reversed?