Show Notes
In this episode Adam explores what it takes to use surprise effectively as an integral part of a challenger’s strategy. His guest is Kyrsten Halley, the former Marketing Director of Aldi UK, part of a team that for years has been putting the purposefully unexpected into the drudgery of the weekly grocery shop. One of the key ways Aldi has grown to become one of the Big Four in the UK.
Adam and Kyrsten unpack how and why a discount supermarket came to offer the world's best champagne for £14.99, restaurant-quality lobster tails at Christmas, and a kayak in the middle aisle: where the real value lies for them in being consistently surprising, and the ‘share of heart’ they look to build through it. And why none of that worked without a real rigour and discipline across the business underpinning it.
The conversation explores:
How ‘delighting the customer with surprise’ can create that ‘chink of open-mindedness’ Aldi needs to grow How the origin of so much of what Aldi does lies in its challenger roots as a Democratiser – making goods available that many UK shoppers would have historically felt they couldn’t afford How the constraints of Aldi’s discount format stimulated the thinking around their famous ‘Special Buys’ The strong relationships between the different areas of the business, and why they are so important. The codes of premium private label they felt they could and couldn’t break Why being consistently surprising, week in week out, really helps find the right boundaries with your audience Why Aldi maintains a challenger mindset even though they are now the fourth biggest UK supermarket What it really means to make a brave idea feel obvious to the rest of the business.
This conversation also formed part of the research for eatbigfish's Cannes Lions 2026 session, "The Startling Power of Surprise" with The Uncensored CMO Jon Evans— the latest chapter in the multi-year Cost of Dull project. For more on the Cost of Dull and the effective strategic use of Surprise, visit eatbigfish.com.
___
Let's Make This More Interesting is a podcast from eatbigfish: the strategic consultancy that helps ambitious Challengers to grow.
Follow Adam on Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/adam-morgan-3a473a/
Thanks to our editor Ruth and our producer Rachael. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from Let's Make This More Interesting
In this episode of Let’s Make This More Interesting from eatbigfish, Adam explores what it takes to be more interesting in a very different medium: stop frame animation. Madga Osinska, today’s guest, is a director of short films and commercials for the world-famous Aardman Animations, besides her own projects, and a winner of jury prizes throughout Europe for her work.
What does it take to be interesting enough for people to brave the New York City subway to come and join you on a cold, wet, Tuesday night? Every Tuesday night? For two years?
How engaging do you have to be, really, to break inertia? To disrupt beliefs? And what does that take in your communication and in your culture?
In this second part of the conversation with Rory Sutherland, Vice Chairman of Ogilvy and behavioural science evangelist, we discuss why Rory feels we are thinking in entirely the wrong way about the payback for marketing, and the different way we need to go about finding those big, engaging ideas that will disproportionately impact the success of our business.
What is the value of surprise to us in becoming more interesting? And how does one of today's most stimulating thinkers stay so consistently surprising himself? In Part 1 of a two part conversation, Adam sits down with Rory Sutherland - Vice Chairman of Ogilvy, behavioural science evangelist, and endlessly fascinating reframer of what we thought we knew - to talk about why surprise matters. As he points out, sometimes the right thing to be is completely unsurprising: there will always be, after all "a market for "the drearily predictable." But if you're trying to change behaviour - to challenge, disrupt, or eat the big fish - then surprise becomes essential. Because the brain isn't built to notice what it expects. It's built to notice what breaks the pattern.