Identity/Crisis

Antizionism and the American Left’s Jewish Problem — with Shaul Kelner

Identity/Crisis

Show Notes

Antizionism has become a badge of belonging—and a tool of exclusion. On this episode of Identity/Crisis, Yehuda Kurtzer speaks with Shaul Kelner, professor of Jewish Studies and Sociology at Vanderbilt University, about how anti-Zionism operates not only as an argument but as a movement culture—shaping who belongs on the American left and what counts as “moral.” Together, they explore what it would mean to respond with clarity without collapsing every critique of Israel into the same category.

You can now sponsor an episode of Identity/Crisis. Click HERE to learn more.

JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST FOR MORE HARTMAN IDEAS

Here’s more from the Shalom Hartman Institute this week:

Read Shaul Kelner’s article “American Antizionism” and subscribe to Sources: A Journal of Jewish Ideas.

Learn more about Rabbanut North America, our three-year rabbinic ordination program, and the newest cohort!

More from Identity/Crisis

Oct 20, 2026

In an age of rising hate speech, can liberalism protect the Jews?

Oct 13, 2026

With Israel's elections just weeks away, what vision for the country's future will ultimately prevail?

Oct 6, 2026

Three years after October 7, what are Israel’s possibilities for healing, renewal, and a different future?

Sep 29, 2026

What does the rise in settler violence in the West Bank reveal about the future of Israel?

Sep 22, 2026

Are religious liberty and liberal democracy a natural match or are they destined to be in conflict?

See all episodes →