Should Jews Proselytize? & Dueling Rabbis PART 2 with Sharon Brous & David Ingber
Being Jewish with Jonah PlattShow Notes
Host Jonah Platt moderates part two of a spirited conversation between Rabbi Sharon Brous (IKAR, Los Angeles) and Rabbi David Ingber (Romemu, New York) about how Jewish leaders should balance moral self-critique of Israel with addressing antisemitism, especially after October 7. Ingber argues progressive Jews and rabbis overemphasize public Jewish self-criticism, undercall out antisemitism and extremism from allies, and should name today’s anti-Zionism as an ever-evolving hate movement that erases Jewish self-determination. Brous defends the Jewish tradition of teshuvah and accountability, urges speaking against West Bank settler violence and occupation, and warns that labeling all criticism or Palestinian solidarity as antisemitic blunts the response to real threats. They also debate U.S. politics, liberal democracy’s role in Jewish safety, Jewish political “homelessness,” and the inclusion of anti-Zionist Jews.
Ultimately, the conversation models a deeply Jewish tradition of debate, machloket l’shem shamayim, while emphasizing unity, responsibility, and the need to continue investing in community and the next generation.
Topics Include: Trading ideas on whether anti-Zionism is a form of modern antisemitism The responsibility of rabbis to address West Bank settler violence and Jewish extremism References to Baruch Goldstein and the Cave of the Patriarchs massacre as a moral comparison The role of Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iran in shaping Jewish security concerns The influence of social media platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Twitter/X on Israel narratives Criticism of language like “apartheid” in discussions about Israel and Palestine The symbolism of the watermelon flag in pro-Palestinian activism Gavin Newsom and his appearance on Pod Save America The importance of protecting liberal democracy for Jewish safety in America Failures in Jewish education, including overreliance on programs like Birthright Israel The role of JCCs (Jewish Community Centers) and synagogues in strengthening Jewish life The need for machloket l’shem shamayim (debate for the sake of heaven) in shaping the Jewish future
A special thanks to our partners on this episode: Charles and Lynn Schusterman Family Philanthropies https://www.schusterman.org Crown Family Philanthropies https://crownfamilyphilanthropies.org/ Jim Joseph Foundation https://jimjosephfoundation.org/
Mentioned In The Episode: Why Don’t Jews Proselytize? Conversion History The Converso: Jews converting to Christianity in Spain and Portugal in the 1300s Ruth: The First Jewish Convert How Many Jews Are In The World? The Jewish Birthrate Jewish Intermarriage Rates Our Epidemic of Loneliness and Isolation (U.S. Public Health Service) American’s Religious Engagement Stays Low Global “Wellness” Business Grows to $6.8 Trillion Jewish Prayers and Their Meanings How to Become Jewish
Sharon Brous Instagram Rabbi David Ingber IKAR Romemu 'My mother cried out one last time': Palestinian boy, 12, describes how Israeli forces killed his family in car Surveillance soldiers charge sexism a factor in their Oct. 7 warnings being ignored Who was Baruch Goldstein? Massacre in Hebron Silence is not solidarity: Diaspora Jews must speak when Israel strays What is Cheshbon Hanefesh? Pogroms Wave of settler attacks against Palestinian herders reported in central West Bank Fourth suspect arrested over Jewish charity ambulance arson attack The Importance of Tochachah-Rebuke Anti-Trump rallies hit thousands of US cities for 'No Kings' protest Explosion rocks Amsterdam Jewish school in what mayor says is ‘targeted attack’ against Jewish community As A Jew: Reclaiming Our Story from Those Who Blame, Shame, and Try to Erase Us Newsom ramps up his criticism of Israel, accuses Netanyahu of leading Trump into war with Iran Horseshoe Theory in American Politics The Z Word: Reclaiming Zionism Protocols of the Elders of Zion Venezuelan VP: US attack capturing Maduro has 'Zionist undertones' Renee Good was shot
More from Being Jewish with Jonah Platt
In the first episode of our Jewish American Summit series, Jonah sits down with Steve Hilton, Republican candidate for California governor, for a candid conversation about antisemitism, Jewish safety, and the future of the Golden State.
What does it mean to be unapologetically Jewish in an industry that has often encouraged people to hide their identity?
NEW SEGMENT! In the first installment of our new segment “Being Jewish In…” we explore the hostile environment facing Jewish authors, agents and editors in the world of Publishing with acclaimed author and digital publisher Meg Keene, newly appointed editor of the eponymous Meg Keene Books, a new imprint focused on publishing Jewish stories by Jewish authors.
Can a CEO speak out against antisemitism without becoming the story?
On the third anniversary of October 7th, Jonah delivers a powerful and deeply personal open letter to his non-Jewish friends, colleagues, and allies about what it means to stand with the Jewish people. In this special solo episode of Being Jewish, Jonah reflects on the past three years of rising antisemitism, fractured friendships, and the growing isolation of Jewish communities. He addresses the dangerous normalization of anti-Jewish rhetoric, the misunderstanding of Zionism and Jewish identity, and the painful silence of those who have chosen to look away.