
Show Notes
Same money, same returns, same twenty years. One fund charges 0.2%, the other charges 1%. The difference is more than fifty thousand dollars, and Shani Jayamanne ran the numbers before she walked into the studio. Shani is an Investment Specialist at Morningstar, co-host of Investing Compass and co-author of Invest Your Way. Morningstar runs a study twice a year comparing what funds return against what the investors in those funds actually get, and the funds win by 1.2% a year. Shani explains where that gap comes from, why Australians are among the best in the world at closing it, and what that has to do with the fact that someone else decides when your super goes into the market. WHAT YOU'LL GET OUT OF IT The gap between investment returns and investor returns, and exactly what's causing it
Why losses hurt more than twice as much as gains, and the two mistakes that come from it
What a 1% fee really costs you over twenty years
Why more investment options make people less likely to invest at all
What happens to your returns if you miss the ten best days in the market
Lump sum versus dollar cost averaging, and where Ben disagrees with the research
Why the most sophisticated investors tend to have the simplest portfolios
The investment specialist who doesn't pick stocks, and why
CHAPTERS 00:21 Intro 00:44 The biggest mistake Australian investors make 01:30 Mind the Gap: your fund beat you by 1.2% 02:30 Why compulsory super makes Australians better investors 04:00 Loss aversion, and why losses hurt 2.25 times more 06:11 Do men and women invest differently 06:30 Complexity is not sophistication 08:00 Boring is profitable 10:30 The chart a colleague left on her desk 12:00 Why more choice means less action 15:22 Thematic ETFs and the AI question 19:43 Growing up with cash and property and no shares 22:00 Fifty dollars a week on a $56,000 salary 24:16 What changed in how she invests 26:30 What a 1% fee really costs 27:55 Where markets are and what's already priced in 29:27 Lump sum or drip feed, and Ben pushes back 33:24 Advice to her 21 year old self
SHANI JAYAMANNE, MORNINGSTAR Investing Compass on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/investing-compass/id1533956604 Investing Compass on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/70E7mbBaJOFuVQOGhxWsK3 Invest Your Way: https://amzn.to/46qMXAu Morningstar Australia: https://www.morningstar.com.au
Smarter money moves start here. Learn how to cut through the noise, avoid expensive mistakes, and get ahead faster. FREE 7-DAY MONEY CHALLENGES Pick one and see what changes in a week: https://pivotwealth.com.au/challenges/ WORK WITH US Book a no-strings call: https://www.pivotwealth.com.au/booking More about Pivot Wealth: https://www.pivotwealth.com.au BEN'S BOOKS Virgin Millionaire: https://amzn.to/3VFPPDM Replace Your Salary by Investing: https://amzn.to/3J9Ta8g Get Unstuck: https://amzn.to/3xo0MQG All books: https://www.pivotwealth.com.au/books FOLLOW Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/pivotben TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bentalksmoney YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/BenNashPivot Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/pivotwealth/ DISCLAIMER This podcast is for education only and doesn't take into account your personal circumstances. It's not financial advice. If you buy a financial product, read the PDS and TMD, and seek advice tailored to your situation. Ben Nash and Pivot Wealth are authorised representatives of Fish Tacos Pty Ltd, ABN 14 649 248 082, AFSL 533055.
More from Mo Money
Division 296 is live. From 1 July, earnings on the part of your super balance above $3 million get taxed at 30%, and above $10 million the rate is 40%. The narrative is that this is a tax on rich retirees. Ben takes a 38-year-old on $400k with $600k in super, doing nothing more exotic than the standard concessional contribution, and shows them crossing $3 million at 57, three years before they can touch the money. The episode is about what to do with that. Why 30% inside super is a worse deal than 30% in a company or an investment bond, because those structures let you get at the money. Why Siobhan asks everyone rushing into an SMSF the same one-word question. Why a couple gets $3 million each, which makes evening up balances the strategy that matters, and how spouse contribution splitting lets you move 85% of your contributions across years before you can access super. And why Ben would rather land under the cap than over it, because there are no givebacks. WHAT YOU'LL GET OUT OF IT How Division 296 actually works, and what it taxes
The AFR reckons rentvesting is dead now that negative gearing has been wound back. Jack Henderson reckons the AFR has it backwards, and he's paying $3,700 a week in rent while he says it. This one moves fast. Jack explains the valuation method most property investors have never heard of, where a property with two incomes on one title gets valued on its rent instead of on what the neighbours sold for, and walks through the duplex where that difference was worth more than a million dollars. He puts a number on what a dollar of rent is worth in value. He gets specific about the off-the-plan settlements he thinks are about to go wrong, and the capital gains tax bill you can get on a property that never went up. And he ends with the single piece of research he tells every young investor to do before they touch anything. Language warning. Jack talks the way Jack talks. This one isn't for the school run. WHAT YOU'LL GET OUT OF IT Why rentvesting still works without negative gearing, and where it stops making sense
On 12 May the budget killed the bucket company. A 30% minimum tax on trust income was the headline, but the real damage was underneath it, because that tax came with no credit when the money moved on to a company. Stack the two together and business owners were looking at an effective rate over 60% on profit they had already been taxed on once. On 3 September the government released draft legislation that changes the picture, and Ben walks through exactly what it does. There is a window, it closes on 1 July 2028, and if you make a fixed election on your trust before then, the 30% minimum tax doesn't apply. The trade is that a discretionary trust stops being discretionary, forever. Ben runs the numbers on a business making $400k a year and shows a gap of just under $2 million between two owners doing the same thing in different structures. He also covers the strategy the election kills, which is distributing to your adult kids. And he explains why who owns the shares in your bucket company now matters more than it ever has, with a 22-month window that just started. WHAT YOU'LL GET OUT OF IT What a bucket company is and why business owners built their wealth around it
Every second call at the moment ends the same way. The budget has tightened the screws, the pay rise didn't move the needle, so what if we just moved to Singapore? Or Dubai. Or Hong Kong. Ben and Siobhan ran the numbers, and the first thing they found is that Australia is a lower tax country than the UK, Canada, New Zealand and most of Europe. The catch is where we collect it. Almost 43% of every tax dollar in Australia comes from personal income, one of the heaviest reliances on personal income tax in the developed world, and that is exactly why it feels the way it does. From there it gets practical. What you take home on $100k, $250k, $500k and $1 million in Sydney versus Singapore, Hong Kong and Dubai. What those countries charge you instead, from a 60% stamp duty on foreigners to private everything. How you actually get in. The tax bill Australia hands you on the way out. And the two residency tests the ATO uses to decide whether you really left, because the people getting caught aren't the ones who moved, they're the ones who pretended to. WHAT YOU'LL GET OUT OF IT Why Australia's total tax take is below the OECD average, and why it feels worse than that
Hugh Robertson reckons the world changed for Aussie investors on 12 May. For years the playbook was simple. Earn well, borrow, negatively gear into residential property and let the market do the rest. The budget took a fair chunk of that off the table, and now a lot of people with money to put to work are asking the same question. What's the play now? Hugh runs Centaur Financial Services, sits on the Barron's Top 100 adviser list, and has been a mate of Ben's for over a decade, which means he doesn't get to be diplomatic. In this one he walks through exactly what his firm changed in client portfolios after the budget, why they've gone underweight Australian shares, and the asset classes they're now allocating to that they never touched before. We also get into the commercial property pitch flooding everyone's feed, and why two emerging markets ETFs can hold completely different countries. Hugh explains what big tech raising debt tells you about where the US market sits, and puts Ben through the maths question about a 50% fall that trips up almost everyone. Then the honest bit on stock picking, why only around one in ten active managers beats the index over a decade, and what Hugh thinks matters most for investors over the next six to 12 months.