Summary
A recent controversy in the cryptocurrency community centers around the launch of a new trading platform called Paper Trade, which has drawn significant attention and criticism. Initially marketed as a "fair launch" exchange allowing traders to engage in high-leverage trades, Paper Trade allows users to place bets against the house rather than other traders. However, the platform's mechanics have raised concerns, particularly regarding its potential to enable market manipulation and the risks associated with its operational model.
The excitement surrounding Paper Trade quickly turned sour when the team behind the platform announced a change in its roadmap, specifically regarding the transferability of its native token, Paper. Initially, users were led to believe that the token would eventually be transferable, but the team later stated that allowing this could expose the platform to significant risks, including potential attacks that could jeopardize its financial stability. This abrupt shift has left many users feeling misled, as they had pre-deposited substantial amounts of capital based on the initial promises.
As the situation evolves, the trading volume on Paper Trade has plummeted, with reports indicating a drastic decrease in staking revenue. Critics argue that the platform's model resembles a gambling operation more than a legitimate trading venue, leading to questions about its long-term viability. The incident highlights broader issues within the cryptocurrency space regarding transparency, user trust, and the challenges of creating sustainable tokenomics in a rapidly changing market.
Show Notes
Traders tried to lose money fast to earn PAPER. Now the token may never be transferable, and one tracker shows staking revenue fell 93% in a day.
========================================================
Thank you to our sponsor!
Put your crypto to work with Nexo: earn daily interest or borrow funds against your assets on one platform trusted by more than 10 million clients.
Find out more at https://unchainedcrypto.com/go/nexo-podcast-sn.
Geo-restrictions, eligibility and terms apply.
========================================================
Quick favor: We're deciding what Unchained does next; new shows, stream times, what's worth paying for. Our listener survey takes five minutes, it's anonymous, and I read the write-in answers myself. Everyone who takes it can enter a drawing for a free year of Unchained Premium or Bits + Bips Premium. Open through Sunday, October 18.
— Laura
========================================================
PaperTrade drew $140 million in pre-deposits and for one day flipped Nasdaq's daily notional volume by letting traders take up to 1,000x leverage against the house, with a PAPER token as the rebate for losing. Then the team announced it no longer plans to make PAPER transferable.
Jason Pagoulatos, Head of Markets at Delphi Research, joins Laura Shin to unpack how the protocol works and why the reversal landed so badly. He walks through the house pool that pays winners from losers' margin, the launch-day trader who pushed ETH around on Hyperliquid to move PaperTrade's price feed, and why a transferable PAPER would invite a larger attack.
Pagoulatos says the team's reasoning holds up but calls the change a bait and switch for everyone who deposited under the original rules. With one tracker showing staking revenue down 93% in a day, the conversation ends on what makes any token worth holding: a business that would work without it.
Host:
Laura Shin, Host / Unchained
Guest:
Jason Pagoulatos - Head of Markets at Delphi Research
Timestamps
🎬 00:00 Intro
⚡ 02:01 What PaperTrade is and why it briefly flipped Nasdaq's daily volume
🎰 06:46 How PaperTrade's house pool pays winners and mints PAPER for losers
🚀 10:32 Launch week: $140M in pre-deposits and a price-feed play on day one
💰 15:12 Nexo: Generate daily interest on your crypto or borrow funds against your assets at https://unchainedcrypto.com/go/nexo-podcast-yt
🔒 15:59 Why promise transferability if the risk was already in the docs?
🔄 17:31 Why PaperTrade shelved plans to make PAPER transferable
📉 24:07 Is PaperTrade over after a 93% one-day drop in staking revenue?
🧱 27:52 Why Jason says tokens should be judged like equity in a real business Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More from Unchained
A certificate authority's private key was the number 4 for over a year. Kain, Taylor, and Austin on why the internet's trust schemes are cracking.
Justin Drake says crypto should brace for AI breaking elliptic curves before Q-Day. Project Eleven's Alex Pruden and Conor Deegan weigh in on what's actually at risk.
A hidden implant read Ledger seed phrases off the screen and sent them out over an eSIM. Mark Karpelès and SEAL 911's Jonty discuss what that means for self-custody.
A Ledger reseller's devices shipped with a hidden LTE modem inside. Taylor Monahan lays out how it passed the genuine check and why panicking now costs more.
The boys regroup after TOKEN2049. Ledgers sold through CryptoBilis, an authorized reseller in Malaysia, came with an LTE implant that read seed phrases off the screen, an OpenAI engineer was caught with a listening device, Papertrade launches 1000x perps where losing money mints you tokens, and the hosts argue over Nikita Bier's claim that technical moats are dead.