The Case

Jennifer

The Case

Show Notes

In November of 1989, 16-year-old Jennifer Fay snuck out of her house in Brockton, Massachusetts, looking for a party.

She was never seen again.

More than three decades later, Barstool Sports' Kirk Minihane launched an investigation to find out what happened to Jennifer. In the first episode of this series, Minihane talks to Jennifer's friends and family, piecing together the events of November 14th, 1989, and interviews the detective who investigated her case for nearly a decade.

Follow The Case on Twitter and Instagram @TheCasePodcast. For more information about The Case, visit TheCasePodcast.com. The Case is a Barstool Sports podcast presented by Taser.

You can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/thecasepodcast

More from The Case

Jun 1, 2026

Anne Barber Dunlap was found in the trunk of her car on New Years Day 1996 in Minneapolis. Kirk Minihane sets out to find who is responsible for her murder.

Jun 13, 2025

Kirk provides an update to Season 2's case involving Sandra Birchmore. It was reported yesterday in the local media that two sources are claiming that DNA testing shows Matthew Farwell was not the father to Sandra Birchmore's unborn child.

Aug 29, 2024

Matthew Farwell was arrested Wednesday and arraigned in Federal Court on charges of killing Sandra Birchmore. Farwell first engaged with Birchmore when she was a 13 year old Stoughton Police Explorer. According to court documents filed Tuesday, Farwell strangled Birchmore to death after being told he was the father of her child.

Jun 19, 2024

Kirk sits down with Turtleboy to discuss the the familiar faces in the death of Sandra Birchmore and the Karen Read trial.

Jan 24, 2023

In the Season Two finale of The Case, Kirk describes the hurdles in pursuing justice for Sandra Birchmore. Some new information has come to light from the crime scene and Sandra's family representatives continue to amend the wrongful death lawsuit following new information brought forth in this podcast.

See all episodes →