#405 Why They Left Christianity: Analyzing Real Deconstruction Stories | Matt Schmidt
The Alisa Childers PodcastSummary
A recent discussion explores the phenomenon of faith deconstruction among Christians, focusing on personal narratives that reveal the complexities behind their spiritual journeys. The conversation emphasizes that many individuals who abandon their faith often do so not merely due to intellectual challenges or moral dilemmas, but because their beliefs were built on shaky foundations. The hosts argue that a reliance on certainty about the Bible or personal experiences can lead to cracks in faith when faced with skepticism or alternative viewpoints.
The analysis includes several personal stories from individuals who have deconstructed their faith, highlighting common themes such as the realization that non-Christians can also embody goodness and morality. This realization often prompts questions about the source of their own moral compass and the validity of their beliefs. The hosts stress the importance of understanding that goodness can stem from being created in the image of God, regardless of one's religious affiliation. They caution against equating morality solely with Christian beliefs, suggesting that many people exhibit kindness and ethical behavior without recognizing its divine origin.
Throughout the discussion, the hosts advocate for a faith grounded in the authority of Jesus rather than a rigid adherence to scripture alone. They encourage listeners to engage with those who are questioning their faith by emphasizing the core tenets of Christianity, such as the need for grace and the recognition of human fallibility. The conversation serves as a reminder that addressing the underlying issues of faith deconstruction requires empathy and a focus on the person of Jesus, rather than merely defending doctrinal positions.
Show Notes
In Part 1 of my conversation with Matt Schmidt, we explored his argument that many deconstruction stories reveal a deeper problem: faith that was ultimately built on something other than the person and authority of Jesus Christ.
In Part 2, we put that thesis to the test by watching and analyzing real deconstruction stories posted online. We hear from former Christians whose faith unraveled over questions about morality, the Word of Faith movement, biblical criticism, the Epic of Gilgamesh, the nature of faith, and more.
With each story, we ask four important questions: What was their faith originally built on? What caused the first crack? What replaced that foundation? And was Jesus himself ever really the problem?
Along the way, Matt and I discuss why Christianity must ultimately be grounded in the person, work, and authority of Jesus Christ—and why understanding what someone is actually rejecting may be crucial to helping those who are deconstructing reconsider the faith they left behind.
Webinar Registration: https://www.e360m.org/alisa Fall Training offerings (including the Deconstruction Discussion group): https://www.e360m.org/fall2026 E360 Store with shirts meant to spark conversations: https://e360.printify.me/ -----------------------------------------------------------------
This video is sponsored by:
BRAVE BOOKS Entertainment that Engages the Imagination for Good. Go to www.bravebooks.com/childers for more information Use my code: CHILDERS
GOOD RANCHERS American Meat Delivered Go to https://go.goodranchers.com/alisa for more information. Use my code: ALISA
RANGE LEATHER American-Made Craftsmanship from Wyoming Go to www.rangeleather.com for more information Use my code: ALISA
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Booking: www.alisachilders.com/booking
To Purchase the new CD, “Beauty from the Ash”, go to www.alisachilders.com/music There you can get the CD, backing tracks, string charts, rhythm charts and stems.
Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/alisachilders
To order “Another Gospel”: www.alisachilders.com/another-gospel/ To order “Live Your Truth": www.alisachilders.com/live-your-truth-and-other-lies/ To order “The Deconstruction of Christianity”: https://alisachilders.com/the-deconstruction-of-christianity/
Potential Sponsors: https://alisachilders.com/sponsor-request-form/
More from The Alisa Childers Podcast
When it comes to kids and screens, it's easy to feel like the damage is already done. But here's the good news: It's never too late to make a change, and you don't have to overhaul your entire family overnight.
Why are so many young Christians converting to Roman Catholicism? Is the Catholic Church really the original, unchanged church established by Jesus? And does Rome teach the same gospel we find in Scripture?
Decades ago, Christian philosopher and apologist Francis Schaeffer warned that evangelical Christianity was heading toward what he called “The Great Evangelical Disaster.” He believed that as Christians increasingly accommodated the spirit of the age, compromised biblical authority, and abandoned objective truth, the consequences would be devastating. Looking at the church today, was Schaeffer right?
Hot flashes, brain fog, anxiety, mood swings, sleepless nights... menopause can turn your world upside down! But how do we navigate these very real physical and emotional challenges while remaining faithful to Christ?
What does it look like to remain faithful to Christ when your hormones feel like they’re crashing out?