Weighty Conversations

002. Caitlin Kelly: Athletes Also Struggle with Weight

Weighty Conversations

Show Notes

Caitlin Kelly played competitive softball for eighteen years and was overweight the whole time, cycling through Weight Watchers from age twelve into every season of adulthood that followed. In the second episode of Weighty Conversations, Caitlyn reveals the moment her food noise finally went quiet, and what she's learned about persistence now that her goal is no longer a number on a scale.

Weight loss doesn’t have to be a miserable experience. We can show you how. → joinvineyard.com/join/

More from Weighty Conversations

Oct 15, 2026

One day at school, a boy in the lunchroom pointed at Roseanne’s container of tuna fish and announced she was on a diet. For the next fifty-plus years, she treated those taunts as proof that something was wrong with her. Now in her 60s, she believes for the first time that nothing ever was, and she shows up to every Vineyard support session she can fit on her calendar. Less for herself, more to be there for whoever walks in carrying the same shame that she did. Wherever your story began, the next chapter hasn’t been written yet. We can help you write the one you want. → joinvineyard.com/go/weighty-conversations

Oct 8, 2026

Bridget can't point to a trigger. No injury, no pregnancy, no diagnosis. Just, in her words, something that switched in her body in her late twenties and began a twenty-plus year journey of losing and regaining the same 40 pounds.

Oct 1, 2026

Kevin Ruiz spent years earning his sense of worth entirely through what he could do for other people, as a prosecutor working the heaviest child welfare cases in New York and as a father who'd pushed his own needs aside completely. Here he talks with Dr. Spencer and Summer about the Easter egg hunt and the t-ball game that cracked that belief, the many ups and downs of his journey, and the moment he realized health isn't something you have to earn. Want support on your own journey? We’re ready when you are. joinvineyard.com/join/

Sep 23, 2026

Jamie Selzler can pinpoint the exact moment his weight started to climb: after two weeks at his grandparents' with an unlimited soda fridge at age nine. Decades later, weighing over 600 pounds, he sat next to an endocrinologist on a flight home who handed him her card and told him to call. He never did. Not until a friend told him “I want you to go to my funeral, I don’t want to go to [yours]” did Jamie finally get help.

Sep 3, 2026

Lou Lionetti spent decades not knowing what hunger or fullness actually felt like, eating his feelings, and indulging in “food is love” at every family table until type 2 diabetes and a decade of rising labs caught up with him. In the third episode of Weighty Conversations, Lou shares what finally quieted the noise, and how “consistent, not compulsive” became his mantra for success.

See all episodes →