Financial Autonomy

The Simple Investment Strategy That Beats 89% of Active Funds

Financial Autonomy

Show Notes

Active fund managers have teams of analysts researching companies, watching markets and deciding exactly what their funds should buy and sell.

If anyone should be able to beat the market, surely it is them.

Yet over 15 years, 89% of active Australian share funds failed to do it.

It is a result that challenges one of the most tempting ideas in investing: that more research, more activity and more expert decision-making should produce better returns.

So why does a far simpler investment strategy keep coming out ahead? And what could that mean for the way you are building wealth?

In this episode, Nick and Paul unpack why trying to beat the market can leave investors further behind, and why the latest results strengthen the case for the index-at-the-core approach we favour at Guidance Financial.

They also look at another risk many investors miss. You could own hundreds of companies and still have far more of your wealth riding on the same industries than you realise.

Inside this episode:

Why so many professional fund managers struggle to beat the market

The small group of shares that can have an outsized effect on returns

What investors risk missing when they try to choose the winners themselves

Why a portfolio can look diversified without being properly diversified

What Australian investors may be missing by staying close to home

Why international investing involves more than spreading money between countries

Whether a simpler investment approach could give you a better chance of reaching your goals

At Guidance, we use an index at the core approach. We help clients decide how their investments should be structured, where they should be held and how they fit with their income, super, debt, tax position and long-term goals. You can learn more about how we manage your money here. Are You in Your 30s or 40s and Ready to Make More of Your Money?

If you're earning well but unsure whether you're investing enough, using super wisely or making the right moves, Wealth Builder can give you a clear plan for turning today's income into long-term wealth. Learn more here. Visit our website here: https://www.guidancefs.com.au/ and you can also find all our links here.

General advice disclaimer

More from Financial Autonomy

Oct 21, 2026

UPDATED: This episode was originally published with the wrong episode audio; it has been republished with the correct audio. Thanks for your patience!

Oct 18, 2026

You've worked hard, built up your savings and investments, and spent years making sensible financial decisions. But when was the last time you gave yourself permission to actually enjoy the money you've earned? It's easy to tell yourself you'll take that big holiday, make that purchase or finally start doing the things you've dreamed about once you retire. But what if waiting comes at a cost you haven't considered? In this episode, financial adviser Paul Benson explores one of the trickiest decisions when it comes to building wealth: how much should you put towards your future, and how much should you enjoy today? Through real client conversations and a spending dilemma of his own, Paul challenges the idea that the financially smartest decision is always the best one. And why getting the balance wrong could leave you with regrets that money can't fix. Inside this episode: Why being disciplined with money can sometimes work against you

Oct 13, 2026

You're earning good money, paying down your mortgage and doing all the right things. But are you missing an opportunity to build wealth along the way?

Oct 11, 2026

You've spent decades building your super and retirement is finally within reach. But what if the sharemarket crashes just as you're preparing to stop work? Could you still retire as planned? Would you need to scale back your lifestyle? And could a few bad years in the market affect how long your money lasts? In this episode, Paul Benson explores a retirement risk many people overlook. He reveals why two people with identical savings and investment returns could end up with vastly different outcomes, and what you can do to prepare. Inside this episode: Why the timing of a market downturn matters more as retirement approaches

Oct 6, 2026

You want to retire while you're young enough to enjoy it, with enough money to say yes to the trips, the experiences and more time with the people you love. But how do you feel confident spending your savings when you don't know how long they need to last?

See all episodes →