Chew On This with Dr Anna Colton

Why Nutrition Advice Is So Confusing and How to Eat Without Fear with Dr Federica Amati

Chew On This with Dr Anna Colton

Show Notes

In this episode of Chew On This, I’m joined by nutritional scientist and public health expert Dr Federica Amati for a deeply clarifying conversation about nutrition, gut health, and why food advice has become so confusing. We unpack how misinformation spreads online, why nuance and evidence struggle to compete with punchy wellness trends, and what nutrition science actually tells us about health, risk, and the microbiome. Federica shares her journey into public health and nutrition, and explains why population-level science so often gets misunderstood when it’s applied to individuals. We also explore gut health without fear or rigidity, discussing the microbiome, fermented foods, fibre, and why focusing on abundance rather than restriction matters. Federica offers grounded, practical guidance on eating well without slipping into diet culture or anxiety, including how to think about whole foods, consistency, and flexibility. This episode is a powerful reminder that good nutrition isn’t about perfection or extremes, but about evidence, context, and building a calmer, more trusting relationship with food.

00:51 The Rise of Public Health Awareness 01:35 Challenges in Health Communication 04:54 Federica's Journey into Public Health 10:39 Personalized Medicine and Public Health 15:00 The Importance of Accurate Nutrition Science 19:14 The Microbiome Revolution 20:07 The Gut-Brain Connection: Ancient Wisdom Meets Modern Science 22:30 The Science Behind Gut Microbiome and Health Outcomes 23:48 Dietary Interventions and Gut Health 24:13 Balancing Diet and Mental Health 25:49 Elasticity of the Gut Microbiome 27:51 Top Foods for a Healthy Gut Microbiome 30:51 Healthy Fats and Omega-3s 34:58 Navigating Food Choices and Marketing 36:47 Creating a Healthy Food Environment at Home 38:01 Encouraging Kids to Develop a Positive Relationship with Food 39:22 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Find Fede: Instagram: @dr.fede.amati Buy Federica's book: https://amzn.eu/d/4SalCRY

Find Anna: Website: ⁠https://www.dranna.co.uk/about⁠ Instagram: ⁠https://www.instagram.com/drannacolton⁠ Book (Amazon): ⁠https://www.amazon.com/How-Talk-Children-About-Food/dp/1785120557

More from Chew On This with Dr Anna Colton

Apr 8, 2026

I am so thrilled to have the wonderful Michaela Thomas - clinical psychologist, ADHD specialist, and author of The Lasting Connection - joining me for this fascinating deep dive into the ADHD brain. We’ve talked about neurodivergence on the show before, but rarely do we look at it through the lens of our relationship with food. Michaela completely shifted my perspective by explaining that ADHD isn't just a "focus" problem; it’s a systemic, whole-body regulation issue. We explore everything from the "good girl" conditioning that leads many women to mask their symptoms for decades, to the staggering reality of how internalised criticism eventually manifests as burnout or disordered eating.

Apr 1, 2026

Trigger Warning: This episode does include discussion of eating disorders and disordered eating, so please take care while listening. In this episode of Chew on This, I’m joined by personal trainer, author and trainee eating disorder psychotherapist Elle Mace for an honest conversation about recovery, body image and what it really takes to rebuild a relationship with food. Elle shares her lived experience of anorexia, binge eating disorder and bulimia over a 17-year period, opening up about how early body comparison, people pleasing and low self-worth shaped her struggles, and what finally helped her begin the long road to recovery. We talk about the emotional roots of eating disorders, the chaos of living with food obsession, and the unlearning that recovery demands in a culture that still glorifies restriction. Elle reflects on how her relationship with food has changed from “chaos” to “incredible”, and shares what she has learned through recovery, motherhood, training as a psychotherapist, and writing her forthcoming book Food Freedom. It’s a thoughtful and powerful conversation about recovery, self-understanding, and how a different relationship with food is possible.

Mar 25, 2026

In this episode, I’m joined by Dr Helen Wall, GP, menopause specialist and author of Menopause and ADHD. We explore what’s really happening during perimenopause—not just physically, but in the brain—and why so many women are left feeling anxious, foggy and unlike themselves without understanding why. Helen explains how fluctuating hormones impact mood, memory and emotional regulation, and why so many symptoms have historically been misdiagnosed or dismissed.

Mar 18, 2026

In this episode, I’m joined by registered dietitian and fertility nutrition specialist Ro Huntriss for a thoughtful and reassuring conversation about what the evidence really says when it comes to food, fertility and trying to conceive. We explore why fertility can become such an emotional space to navigate, how nutrition is often one of the first things people reach for when they feel powerless, and why Ro is so passionate about bringing clarity to an area that is often full of misinformation, false promises and anxiety.

Mar 11, 2026

In this episode, I am joined by Charlotte Ord - counselling psychologist, body image specialist, eating disorder specialist, and author of Body Confident You, Body Confident Kid — for a thoughtful conversation about body image, food, control, and the messages we pass on to the next generation. Together, we explore how body image develops, why it becomes so entangled with eating behaviours, and how diet culture, restriction, shame and “food noise” can pull us further away from ourselves.

See all episodes →