The Recovering Radical

I’m Sorry for What I Said as an Evangelical Teenager (with Layne Watkins of the Sinful Sticker Shop)

The Recovering Radical

Show Notes

“Tell me that’s not a cult.”

Altar calls. Hell House. Covenant ceremonies. After years of growing up within ultra-evangelical churches, exclusive theology, and sexy Jesus, Layne Watkins has made a full 180 and left all the charismatic BS behind her. Now she runs the Sinful Sticker Shop, her way of atoning for the embarrassing stories from her past, something that many of us in the exvangelical space can relate to.

In this episode we dive deep into the traumas, the brainwashing, the grief, and yes, even the laguhter that comes after deconstructing and leaving it all behind. We discuss how the church jacked up our bodies, from our drives to our nervous system, and how to find healing on the journey out.

If you were apart of a system and feel embarrassed about your past self, if you still feel the consequences that high-control religion had on you, or if you simply need a laugh, this episode is for you. Join us in a conversation that is both rich and cathartic.

Content warning timestamps:

9:04- 12:33 Domestic violence Suicide Hell/afterlife torture Abortion/teen pregnancy

43:19 Miscarriage

Topics in this episode: Starting a business in the deconstruction niche space Assemblies of God church community Hell houses for Christ Exvangelical community and healing Ego and pride in evangelicalism Loyd Ziegler and Master’s Commission USA cult The culture of financial issues as a young adult Realizing the exclusivity of the church Having relationships and perspective outside of your bubble Captivating by Lisa Bevere and “Jesus is my boyfriend” relationships Sexual suppresion from the church What healthy conversations about sex with your kids actually looks like Trauma gained within high control religion Regulating the nervous system

Follow more of Allison! Instagram- @real_allison_rose TikTok- @real_allison_rose YouTube- @real_allison_rose

Connect with Layne! Shop the Sinful Sticker collection Instagram and TikTok- @sinfulstickershop

#TheRecoveringRadical #Exvangelical #ReligiousTrauma #PurityCultureRecovery #DeconstructionJourney #NervousSystemHealing #ChurchTrauma #RecoveringEvangelical #SpiritualAbuseRecovery

More from The Recovering Radical

Aug 4, 2026

Just because you’re out of church doesn’t mean church is out of you.

Jul 24, 2026

What happens when purity culture doesn't just shame women—but also teaches men they're inherently dangerous?

Jul 13, 2026

“Women can be the most competent person in the room and still get told they’re not good enough to speak.”

Jul 10, 2026

What happens after you leave church? How do you rebuild community after deconstruction without falling into another unhealthy system?

See all episodes →