The Good, The Bad & The Football

Peter Schmeichel: United Need Xhaka, Carrick Deserves The Job & I Should Never Have Left United

The Good, The Bad & The Football

Show Notes

Paddy, Scholesy and Nicky are joined by Manchester United legend Peter Schmeichel to react to Manchester United’s 3-2 win over Liverpool.

They break down how a dominant first-half performance turned into a nervy finish and why United lost control of the game. There’s a deep dive into Kobbie Mainoo’s return under Michael Carrick, his growing influence on the side, and the big midfield debate: who should partner him long-term - Sandro Tonali, Eduardo Camavinga or Adam Wharton? Peter brings up a surprise name who he thinks could fill that role.

Nicky explains why he believes the United head coach role is Carrick’s to lose, while Peter highlights the importance of Steve Holland behind the scenes. There’s also a surprising take from Schmeichel on why he hopes Mainoo doesn’t go to the World Cup with England national football team.

Elsewhere, Peter draws comparisons between Bayern Munich under Vincent Kompany and United’s iconic treble winners and why today’s football can feel over-coached, with Bayern a rare exception. Nicky reveals why United never feared losing under Sir Alex Ferguson, while Peter shares how you could tell what mood Fergie was in and why a certain biscuit tin became legendary at Old Trafford.

There are throwback stories including a fiery dressing-down for United's squad from Graham Taylor of all people, the truth behind that infamous non-handshake between Schmeichel and Gary Neville before the Manchester derby and Nicky reveals just how close he came to joining Real Madrid’s Galacticos team.

Plus: was the 1994 side actually Fergie’s best? Why Scholes and Butt dreaded warming up Schmeichel, how Paul Ince tore into Scholesy after a missed chance, and why Peter hated being chipped in training.

And, the lads tackle the biggest question of all: do dogs need a passport?

If you want to ask the guys anything about football email them at: [email protected].

Follow The Good, The Bad & The Football:

YouTube: www.youtube.com/@goodbadfootballpod

Instagram: @goodbadfootballpod

X/Twitter: @goodbadftblpod

TikTok: goodbadfootballpod

Facebook: www.facebook.com/goodbadfootballpod

Enter for the chance to win an African safari trip for just 99p 👉 www.thatprizeguy.co.uk Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Good, The Bad & The Football

Oct 19, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy welcome Gordon Strachan onto the show to discuss the genius of Sir Alex Ferguson and reflect on a difficult week for Manchester United following Lisandro Martinez's explosive post-match interview.

Oct 12, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy discuss the fallout from Manchester City's 3-0 win at Anfield, despite the talk of Liverpool's intense atmosphere in the build-up and Manchester United's disappointing 1-1 draw with Tottenham in the Premier League.

Sep 29, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy are joined by Mark Ogden to dissect the reports that Manchester City have been found guilty of 114 charges in their court case against the Premier League. What repercussions could they face? What does it mean for their legacy?

Sep 21, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy reflect on Manchester United's drab 1-1 draw with Fulham, as well as Arsenal and Chelsea's surprise defeats.

See all episodes →