Pantheon - Podcasts for Music Lovers

Set Lusting Bruce - Matt Donnelly on Magic, Fool Us, and Bruce Springsteen’s Politics

Pantheon - Podcasts for Music Lovers

Show Notes

Jesse Jackson welcomes Matt Donnelly for his third appearance on a B-side “Set Listing Bruce” episode that detours from Springsteen into Matt’s life in comedy and magic. Matt recounts how a dare from Penn Jillette led him to learn magic with mentor Johnny Thompson, tour with Piff the Magic Dragon, and build routines through problem-solving, tension, and performance. He discusses nerves onstage, the work of writing and “mascot” duties on Penn & Teller: Fool Us, and shares the story of Moxie Jillette being motivated to fool Penn & Teller. They talk about luck and risk in show business, Springsteen’s long-standing political outspokenness, and criticism of the film Deliver Me From Nowhere. Matt plugs upcoming touring plans, Jokers of Magic, Virgin Voyages work, and his podcasts and Patreon.

https://mattdonnellymagic.com/

00:37 Matt Returns

01:25 Vegas Life Update

02:30 Magic Origin Story

03:54 Why Magic Clicked

06:47 Building A Killer Routine

10:35 Performance And Audience Trust

14:12 Nerves And High Stakes

16:46 Fool Us Behind The Scenes

19:41 Mascot Writer Role

21:13 Moxie Pep Talk Twist

24:18 Protecting Moxie’s Wellbeing

24:53 Dream Job Reality Check

27:16 Luck Risks and Connections

29:42 Springsteen Breakthrough Myth

31:53 Bruce Gets Political Again

34:40 Nebraska Biopic Misfire

38:45 What’s Next for Matt

40:13 Cruise Ship Pros and Cons

41:29 Podcasts and Communities

44:07 Closing Wishes and Song Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Pantheon - Podcasts for Music Lovers

Oct 22, 2026

Armored Saint’s John Bush and Type O Negative’s Kenny Hickey join Metal Mayhem ROC for two conversations about new music and enduring legacies. Jon Verno talks with Bush about Emotion Factory Reset, touring with Metal Church, and balancing new songs with fan favorites. Bush also shares updates on Anthrax-era shows and Electric Spaghetti.

Oct 22, 2026

In Episode 381 of History in Five Songs with Martin Popoff, Martin examines how legendary rock and metal bands responded to major lineup, stylistic, and production changes on the albums that followed the shakeups. He compares records by Deep Purple, David Lee Roth, and others to reveal when bands refined a new sound, played it safe, or reached new creative heights.

Oct 21, 2026

In Episode 380 of History in Five Songs with Martin Popoff, Martin looks back at the modest metal victories of the '90s. From hair-metal revivals and thrash tours to underground bands earning major-label attention and surprising gold and platinum certifications, Martin recalls the excitement of championing metal during its supposedly “dead” era.

Oct 21, 2026

On the 81th Episode of the Album Review Crew of Shout It Out Loudcast, Tom & Zeus welcome back special guest The King of TNA Wrestling and musician, Frankie Kazarian to review the 1980 transitional album from Black Sabbath, "Heaven And Hell!"

Oct 20, 2026

In Episode 379 of History in Five Songs with Martin Popoff, Martin explores albums with unexpectedly high sales certifications. He highlights unusual successes across live albums, greatest hits compilations, soundtracks, EPs, and unconventional studio records, spotlighting artists including Cheap Trick, Kiss, and the Clash.

See all episodes →