
You Say Jesus Didn't Really Rise? Addressing Common Skeptic Challenges to the Resurrection S2E15
The Christian Clinician: Faith-Based Functional Medicine for Christian Women in MidlifeShow Notes
In this episode of The Christian Clinician, host Dr. Tanya Paynter, a wellness expert who integrates faith and evidence-based medicine, tackles the most common objections to the resurrection of Jesus. Drawing on her personal journey through doubt, extensive historical and theological research, and her academic background, she breaks down skeptical arguments and shares logical, evidence-based responses. The discussion covers theories such as mass hallucination, metaphorical resurrection, legend development, the wrong tomb, the swoon theory, and the stolen body theory, offering listeners reasoned rebuttals and practical advice for addressing these issues. Dr. Tanya Paynter empowers listeners with confidence in the historical reliability of the resurrection, emphasizing its foundational impact on faith and everyday life. The episode concludes with a reflection on how understanding the resurrection can reshape priorities and spiritual commitment. Today's Action Steps Reflect on the evidence for the resurrection and consider which objections you struggle with most. Make time to research and understand historical and theological sources to strengthen your faith. Journal or meditate on how the resurrection affects your personal priorities and relationship with God. Engage in conversations about these objections with others to practice articulating logical, evidence-based responses. Evaluate your daily routine for ways to prioritize spiritual connection and growth.
Resources Mentioned in Today's Episode Strobel, Lee. The Case for Christ. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1998. Edwards, William D., Wesley J. Gabel, and Floyd E. Hosmer. “On the Physical Death of Jesus Christ.” JAMA 255, no. 11 (March 21, 1986): 1455–63. Groothuis, Douglas. Christian Apologetics: A Comprehensive Case for Biblical Faith. 2nd ed. Downer’s Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2022. Habermas, Gary R. The Historical Jesus: Ancient Evidence for the Life of Christ. 11th ed. Joplin, MO: College Press Publishing Company, 1996. Habermas, Gary R. The Risen Jesus and Future Hope. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 2003. Habermas, Gary R., and Michael R. Licona. The Case for the Resurrection of Jesus. Grand Rapids, MI: Kregel Publications, 2004. Strauss, Mark L. Four Portraits, One Jesus: A Survey of Jesus and the Gospels. 2nd ed. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2007.
Time Stamps 00:00:00 – Introduction and importance of the resurrection 00:00:54 – Overview of common objections addressed in this episode 00:03:08 – Personal story of doubt and search for logical evidence 00:03:36 – Mass hallucination objection debunked 00:05:50 – Individual hallucination and large group appearances explained 00:06:12 – Metaphorical resurrection theory rebuttal 00:07:17 – Addressing the legend and myth development theory 00:09:24 – Variations in the Gospel accounts and authenticity of eyewitness testimony 00:15:25 – Wrong tomb theory and its rebuttal 00:16:09 – The swoon theory and medical evidence against it 00:24:44 – The stolen body theory and why it’s unlikely 00:29:00 – Role of women witnesses and implications for historical accuracy 00:30:21 – Impact of resurrection on daily life and faith 00:33:00 – Prioritizing spiritual growth and relationship with God 00:37:36 – Focusing on the deeper meaning of the resurrection
Dr. Tanya Paynter is a passionate wellness expert, podcast host, and Christian scholar dedicated to linking faith and evidence-based practices for holistic health. Through her podcast The Christian Clinician, she guides listeners in exploring the intersection of wellness and spirituality, helping them revitalize their health and renew their faith with confidence and research-driven insight. Follow The Christian Clinician on Social Media: YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@thechristianclinician Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheChristianClinician Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/christianclinician/
More from The Christian Clinician: Faith-Based Functional Medicine for Christian Women in Midlife
If your anxiety treatment isn’t working the way you hoped, the problem may not be the treatment itself — it may be that you haven’t identified the anxiety triggers actually driving your symptoms. The missing piece may be something you haven’t connected to anxiety at all, which is why changing medications, adding supplements, or trying another stress-management strategy may not be enough. In this episode of The Christian Clinician, Dr. Tanya Paynter looks at some of the less obvious contributors to anxiety that don’t always get much attention in a conventional anxiety workup. Instead of assuming every case of anxiety needs the same solution, she walks through how patterns in your symptoms can help point you toward the kinds of anxiety treatment that are more likely to fit what’s actually going on. Could a supplement that seems perfectly reasonable on paper be the wrong choice for you once your nutrient status, genetics, and everything else you’re taking are considered? Could something as ordinary as when you have your coffee, how you use your phone, or where you feel anxiety in your body offer clues about what’s driving it? And could two episodes that you both call “anxiety” actually be coming from very different places? Some of the clues can be measured. Others require paying attention to patterns you may have never thought were relevant. And some take the investigation in an entirely different direction — into the things you believe about yourself, the relationships around you, and even assumptions about God that you may consciously reject but still react to as though they were true. In This Episode, You’ll Explore: Why conventional anxiety treatment doesn’t work for everyone How to start identifying your underlying anxiety triggers Which labs are worth discussing with your healthcare provider Why expensive specialty testing isn’t necessarily the best place to start One five minute practice that can point you to what you’ve been missing How to distinguish biochemical anxiety (anxiety as a result of a physical imbalance) from anxiety tied to thoughts, emotions, or circumstances Identifying how control may contribute How beliefs (sometimes unconscious beliefs) about yourself and God can become part of the anxiety picture How relationships impact anxiety (are yours helpful or harmful?)
High-functioning anxiety doesn’t always look like anxiety. It can look like productivity, overthinking, perfectionism, staying busy, taking care of everyone else, and feeling responsible for outcomes you were never meant to control. In this episode, Dr. Tanya Paynter talks with licensed professional counselor Ashley Hageman about anxiety in Christian women, the need for control, shame, over-responsibility, faith, and why “just have more faith” can make things worse instead of better.
Why am I anxious for no reason? If you've tried everything — cut the caffeine, managed your stress, worked on trusting God more — and anxiety is still your default, it's time to dig deeper. In this episode, Dr. Tanya Paynter explores overlooked physical, mental, emotional, spiritual, and relational contributors that anxiety conversations almost never explore — including food sensitivities, supplement interactions, blood sugar, genetic factors, toxic relationships, and the beliefs about God your body holds onto even when your mind thinks you've settled them. If anxiety feels like a mystery you can't solve, this episode is your starting point.
Dr. Paynter says: "I have people coming to me saying some people say I should be on the carnivore diet, and other people are swearing it has to be vegan — and you have testimonies for both extremes. What am I supposed to do with that?"
Many Christian women are dealing with chronic symptoms — anxiety, fatigue, hormone imbalance, thyroid issues, gut problems, insomnia, or just feeling "off" — and can't find answers in labs, supplements, or treatment plans alone. In this Season 4 opener, Dr. Tanya Paynter introduces Theophysiology: the framework that will shape the entire season. If your physical symptoms are the last thing to manifest, not the first, then healing requires looking at all five areas of health — physical, mental, emotional, spiritual, and relational — and understanding how each one shapes the others. If you've been doing everything right and still don't feel well, this episode is your starting point.