Previously On with Jillian Bonanne

The Shards Episodes 3 and 4 Recap + Reactions | Really Rhonda and Robert's Party

Previously On with Jillian Bonanne

Show Notes

The Shards officially has us hooked! Jillian and Tyler break down Episodes 3 & 4 as another student disappears, Bret becomes increasingly convinced that something sinister is happening around him, and Robert Mallory somehow manages to become even more suspicious while dancing in leather pants. From Really Rhonda’s disappearance and to even more creepy phone calls, mysterious vans and a party that goes completely off the rails, the mystery of The Trawler is only getting darker but the vibes are somehow still up for Robert Mallory's party Plus, Jillian and Tyler rank the Top 5 Characters Lying to Our Faces, run through their growing list of Trawler suspects, and try to figure out whether Bret is actually getting closer to the truth or if the show is intentionally messing with all of us. And, of course, Tyler’s Takes returns for everything from homecoming and fake IDs to ’80s porn, Heaven’s Gate, needle drops and the truly important question: what the hell is Cha Cha doing north of the 10?

00:00:00 Reenactment - Really Rhonda Water 00:04:14 Intro to pod 00:07:59 Recap - Episode 3 00:13:17 Recap - Episode 4 00:23:28 Top 5 Lying to Our Faces 00:25:56 Debbie, Liz, and Terry 00:31:27 Susan Reynolds 00:37:49 Robert Mallory 00:41:32 Bret Ellis 00:45:05 The Trawler 00:48:16 Thom Wright 00:49:58 Whodunit? 00:52:33 Dance Off 00:54:22 Tyler's Takes

Thank you to Matt Buechele (@mattbooshell) for creating our new theme song. You can listen to "Sunscreen" on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/artist/1gFHHF3QyQxjbbKXV3qLu9

Buy our merch: ⁠https://www.etsy.com/shop/PreviouslyOnTeenTV⁠ Follow Previously On Teen TV on Instagram: ⁠⁠https://www.instagram.com/previouslyon_teentv/ Follow Previously On Teen TV on TikTok: ⁠⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@previouslyon_teentv⁠⁠ Subscribe to our YouTube: ⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCe2lgvvZGKMrQ8v24FmDdWQ?sub_confirmation=1⁠

More from Previously On with Jillian Bonanne

Oct 19, 2026

This week on Previously On This Week, we're talking about the casting news, TV obsessions, book boyfriends, and upcoming romances that have completely taken over my brain! First up, the Fourth Wing adaptation finally has its Violet and Xaden! I'm breaking down the casting of Esther McGregor and Emilio Sakraya, why I'm already obsessed, and why everyone needs to trust the process. Plus, I'm officially a Felicity girl! I'm watching the iconic '90s teen drama for the first time, and I have THOUGHTS about the love triangle of the century. Spoiler alert: I'm Team Ben, and I'm not backing down. We're also talking about the return of HBO's Girls, Milo Manheim entering his rom-com era with a Serendipity remake, and my latest Off Campus book obsession as I make my way through John Logan and Grace's love story in The Mistake. Plus, I'm sharing my love for the new Sense and Sensibility, the upcoming Bella from Barney's series from the creators of Gossip Girl and The O.C., and Harry Styles' emotional tribute to Liam Payne that had this One Direction girl in tears. And of course, we're looking ahead to what's next, including Nobody Wants This Season 3 and the Formula 1 romance Drive: The Pretenders. Fake engagement? Enemies to lovers? Racing drivers? SIGN ME UP. It's another week of fictional men, nostalgic TV, romance, and absolutely no chill. Let's get into it!

Oct 12, 2026

Previously On This Week is BACK, and we've got a lot to catch up on! Jillian is breaking down her Top 5 obsessions of the week, the latest in tv news, and all the fangirl moments living rent-free in her head. This week, we're talking about Chris Briney bringing back the art of yearning in a Verizon commercial, why everyone needs to stop sleeping on Drawn Together, the Boys of Tommen series, and the Hunger Games press tour already delivering iconic fashion moments. Plus, buckle up because Jillian breaks down how car racing romances are in our future with Drive the Pretenders, Campus Drivers, and Throttled starring Josh Heuston and Nicole Wallace. And yes, we're still mourning the cancellation of Motorheads...it was ahead of its time! Then it's time for some boots-on-the-ground fangirl reporting! Jillian recaps the One Tree Hill basketball game, an Off Campus coffee shop sighting, another Harry Styles concert, and a potential Paul Wesley sighting in the wild. Was it actually him? The investigation continues. From fictional boyfriends to real-life fangirl adventures, consider this your weekly pop culture gossip sesh with a friend who's just as obsessed as you are. New episodes of Previously On This Week every Monday!

Oct 8, 2026

Netflix is officially back in its teen drama era, and I'm breaking down everything I loved about Crew Girl! From elite boarding school drama and underdog sports moments to a love triangle that's already dividing us, this show has all the ingredients of our favorite YA dramas. This week on Previously On, I'm diving into Tegan's unexpected move to Eagles Cove, her journey from outsider to the heart of the Easton crew team, and the friendships that made us fall in love with this group. I'm counting down our Top 5 "The Crew Finally Became a Crew" Moments, breaking down the Cam vs. Josh love triangle (and revealing which team I'm on!), and discussing all those season finale cliffhangers. Plus, I'm talking Josh's redemption arc, Tegan's complicated family drama, the future of Easton's girls' rowing team, and everything I'm hoping to see in Season 2. Because who knew a show about rowing could have us this emotionally invested in the stroke seat?! Grab your oars, pick your team, and let's get into it! Spoilers ahead for Crew Girl Season 1

Oct 5, 2026

In this episode of Previously On, Jillian is joined by Tyler to talk all about Prime Video’s The Love Hypothesis, a STEM rom-com that takes fake dating and awkward (but hot) scientists finding love, and turns it into exactly the kind of movie we love talking about. Jillian gets into reading the book, its Reylo fanfic origins, and why she didn't know what to make of the movie at first, but it ended up winning her over in the end, and Tyler gives his official take as someone who, according to Jillian, looks like he works in a lab. Then we’re counting down our Top 5 Incorrect Hypotheses because these smart scientists get a lot wrong. We break down Olive’s feelings for Jeremy, everyone putting Tom Benton on a pedestal, the discovery that Dr. Evil might actually have a heart, and the biggest scientific error of them all: Olive believing the dating was ever really fake. We also rank some of this year’s rom-coms and talk about where The Love Hypothesis lands in the fake-dating hall of fame.

Sep 21, 2026

The Pogues have officially reached the end of the road. Jillian is joined by Claire to break down the fifth and final season of Outer Banks and say goodbye to one of our favorite teen dramas. After five seasons of treasure hunts, near-death experiences, international adventures, and some truly unhinged decisions, did the series stick the landing? We look back at our Season 5 predictions (including Jillian’s slightly delusional Kiara and Rafe agenda), discuss how the show handled the aftermath of JJ’s death, and why this finally felt like Kiara’s season. Plus, we get into Rafe’s full-circle storyline, John B. and Sarah’s happy ending, the return of familiar faces, the Royal Merchant gold coming back into play, and why the final hurricane was the perfect way to bring the story back to its Season 1 roots. Then, for our final Outer Banks Top 5, we’re counting down the Top 5 Full-Circle Moments We Loved, from bringing back Pogues vs. Kooks to storylines we thought the show had forgotten completely. We also rank all five seasons and talk about why, no matter how wild this show got, the friendship, found family, romance, and absolute chaos kept us coming back. Five seasons. Six years. Countless stolen boats. Somehow even more treasure. We’ll miss you, Pogues. And don’t worry — if that Outer Banks prequel happens, we’ll be back.

See all episodes →