The Modern Manager

403: How To Escape The Either/Or Trap And Make Better Decisions

The Modern Manager

Show Notes

You’re stuck between two options, going back and forth, trying to figure out the “right” choice. Should you hire or not? Change systems or stay the same? Restructure or keep things as they are? The more you think about it, the more stuck you feel.

It’s easy to assume the answer is hidden somewhere between those two choices, but often, that’s the real problem. You’re treating a complex decision as if it only has two possible paths.

In this quick lesson, I share five practical strategies to help you break out of binary thinking and expand your options.

By the end of this lesson, you’ll know how to approach decisions more creatively, uncover better solutions, and move forward with greater confidence, without feeling stuck between “either” and “or.”

Conversation Topics (00:00) Why either-or thinking keeps you stuck in tough decisions (00:59) How binary thinking limits better, more creative solutions (01:30) Strategy 1: Generate “options within options” to expand your choices (03:03) Strategy 2: Challenge the assumptions behind your choices (03:58) Strategy 3: Sequence decisions instead of treating them as permanent (04:20) [Extended Episode] Strategy 4: Create hybrid solutions that combine the best of both options (04:44) [Extended Episode] Strategy 5: Reframe decisions from different stakeholder perspectives (05:20) How to recognize when you’re stuck in either-or thinking (05:40) Your challenge: Apply one strategy to a current decision (06:00) Why better decisions come from expanding, not narrowing, your options

📚 Additional Resources ✨ Read the transcript: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1CqY5XO5bUVxKGO8gxqEneN4DtYWGOoVykBuwYM6C1K4/edit?usp=sharing

✨ Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/leadershipwithmamie/

✨ Visit my website for more: https://www.mamieks.com/

✨ Level up your skills: https://themodernmanager.com/replaybundle

✨ Subscribe to my YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7jhYz8b16g1SsLia4EhO5w?sub_confirmation=1

The Modern Manager is a leadership podcast for rockstar managers who want to create a working environment where people thrive and great work gets done.

Follow The Modern Manager on your favorite podcast platform so you won’t miss an episode!

#LeadershipDevelopment #ManagementSkills #DecisionMaking #ProblemSolving #StrategicThinking #LeadershipSkills #ManagerMindset #WorkplaceSuccess #ProfessionalGrowth #CriticalThinking #LeadershipHabits #TheModernManager

More from The Modern Manager

Oct 20, 2026

Want to overcome resistance to change on your team? Start by noticing that the loudest pushback usually isn't the real problem. Hidden resistance often looks like nodding along in the meeting, then quietly sticking to the old way. Expert Tony Chatman explains why change threatens people's sense of identity, how to tell agreement from true buy-in, why the trusted voices on your team matter more than your title, and what AI adoption reveals about the fear of starting over. 💌 Get new episodes and one-page takeaways by email: https://www.themodernmanager.com Guest Bio

Oct 13, 2026

It's 4:47 on Thursday, the report still isn't in, and the story forming in your head is that they just don't care. But that story is usually wrong, and it's also the easiest one to tell because it means you don't have to look at anything you did. This episode gives you a three-question framework, person, process, promise, to find where a performance problem actually lives before you walk into a feedback conversation assuming the worst.

Oct 6, 2026

Some days, gratitude feels like something for people with calmer inboxes. Someone dropped the ball, you're three meetings deep, and "thank you" is the last thing on your mind. But gratitude that only shows up on easy days never shows up at all. Learn what grateful leadership really looks like, how to appreciate the team member you struggle with, why a pizza party can backfire, and the one question that reveals how each person wants to be recognized. We could all use a bit more gratitude, so this one’s for you.

Sep 29, 2026

Planning an agenda feels like it takes forever, so too often, we skip it or do it poorly at the last minute. But that’s often because we treat each meeting like we’re starting from scratch. Instead, what if you perfected your weekly team meeting, brainstorm session or any other type of meeting you hold regularly and then just used that same agenda structure again so meeting prep becomes fast and easy? That’s called creating a meeting portfolio. This episode breaks down exactly how to design a meeting once, so it works every single time you use it. Conversation Topics (00:00) Introduction: The Hidden Cost of Winging Your Meetings (01:06) What Is a Meeting Portfolio? (Episode Overview) (01:36) Why Most Managers Reinvent Every Meeting From Scratch (02:23) Building the Core Template: Name, Purpose, and Structure (03:57) Adding Pre-Work to Complete Your Template (05:01) Iterating Until Your Meeting Design Actually Works (05:38) Your Action Step: Build and Use Your First Template (06:44) Closing Thoughts and Recap Additional Resources ✨ Read the full transcript: 427-transcript ✨ Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/leadershipwithmamie/ ✨ Visit my website for more: https://www.themodernmanager.com/ ✨ Subscribe to my YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7jhYz8b16g1SsLia4EhO5w?sub_confirmation=1 Join my newsletter to get episodes and key takeaways delivered directly to your inbox: https://www.themodernmanager.com

Sep 22, 2026

Most of what happens in a workday, from how you open a meeting to how you respond to bad news, runs on autopilot. Habits, not decisions, are doing the heavy lifting. Behavior scientist BJ Fogg explains why willpower fails, why "bad habits" aren't really the enemy, and how one tiny action, done consistently, can quietly reshape how you see yourself as a leader, teammate, and person.

See all episodes →