Complexified

The “Pastors In Name Only”: The New (Old) Fight Over Who Counts As Christian

Complexified

Show Notes

Why Democratic pastors are being attacked for their faith, not merely their politics.

Pastors, seminarians and other faith leaders are running for office as Democrats across the country. Their campaigns are making progressive Christianity newly visible—and prompting opponents to challenge not only their politics, but their legitimacy as Christians.

RNS national reporter Jack Jenkins joins Amanda to examine James Talarico’s rise, attacks involving a “Satanist wedding” and biblical inerrancy, and the theological dispute between Raphael Warnock and Mike Johnson over Matthew 25. Do these candidates represent a durable religious political force, or are they a temporary reaction to Trump? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Complexified

Oct 20, 2026

Religion has always been part of American politics.

Oct 12, 2026

Televangelist Jim Bakker is dead at 86. And whatever else can be said about him, he was a true American original.

Oct 5, 2026

Soldiers are trained for physical combat. But war also confronts them with death, killing, grief, guilt and questions of meaning.

Sep 28, 2026

Across YouTube, podcasts and church conferences, a new group of pastors and influencers is promoting an openly racist and baldly antisemitic vision of Christian America. They present themselves not as extremists, but as respectable religious leaders defending truths that others are afraid to say.

Sep 21, 2026

Republican leaders across Texas are repeatedly warning that Sharia is an urgent threat to the state- making it a rallying cry as we head into the midterm elections. The Muslim community, who has long stayed quiet, is now organizing and speaking out.

See all episodes →