Sandra Birchmore Mental Health History, Blood Evidence in Missing VA Mom Trial, and “Devil Made Me Do It” Case, with Tony Brueski
MK True CrimeSummary
The murder trial of Naresh Bhatt, accused of killing and dismembering his wife Mumta Bhatt, continues to unfold with compelling evidence presented in court. The prosecution argues that Bhatt, who has pleaded not guilty, is responsible for his wife's disappearance and alleged murder, which occurred in July 2024. Key evidence includes surveillance footage showing Bhatt purchasing gloves and kitchen knives shortly before Mumta's disappearance, as well as video of him disposing of bags in a trash compactor, which the prosecution suggests may contain body parts.
Witness testimonies further complicate Bhatt's defense. A Home Depot employee identified him in surveillance footage buying items consistent with the alleged crime, while a gas station worker reported seeing him acting suspiciously after the disappearance. Forensic evidence, including blood found in the couple's home and a battery-operated saw linked to Bhatt, strengthens the prosecution's case. The trial is expected to last several weeks, with jurors tasked with interpreting the circumstantial evidence that paints a grim picture of Bhatt's actions.
In a separate case, the trial of Matthew Farwell for the murder of Sandra Birchmore is also making headlines. Farwell faces serious allegations, including a history of grooming Birchmore from a young age. Testimonies reveal that he was present in her life during critical moments, including her pregnancy. The prosecution has introduced DNA evidence linking Farwell to the crime, while the defense attempts to argue that Birchmore may have taken her own life. The case highlights issues of power dynamics and abuse, raising questions about the responsibility of those in positions of authority.
Both trials reflect the complexities of criminal cases where circumstantial evidence and personal histories intertwine, leaving jurors to navigate the murky waters of guilt and innocence.
Show Notes
The MK True Crime Show host Phil Holloway and guest co-host Jonna Spilbor of Positively Legal join the program to discuss updates in the Naresh Bhatt murder trial, the chilling CCTV footage of him making multiple trips to an apartment complex trash compactor, what prosecutors say was likely in those trash bags, the police interview footage jurors saw of Naresh telling investigators about his own honesty, the landscaper Bhatt paid with a reciprocating saw, what forensics experts found in that saw when the landscaper turned it in to police, and later Phil and Jonna are joined Tony Brueski, host of “Hidden Killers with Tony Brueski,” to discuss the Sandra Birchmore trial updates, the defense strategy that played out while Birchmore’s therapist was on the stand, the testimony of Birchmore’s baby’s father, what the medical examiner who conducted Birchmore’s autopsy said she did and didn’t know during the initial autopsy, the unique story of Arne Johnson, whose legal team tried to argue he was not guilty of murdering his landlord and friend by reason of demonic possession in 1981, why famous paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren say he came to be possessed, and more.
Phil Holloway: https://x.com/PhilHollowayEsq
Jonna Spilbor: https://jonnaspilbor.com
Tony Brueski: https://www.youtube.com/@hiddenkillerspod
SelectQuote: Compare top‑rated life insurance options. Visit https://SelectQuote.com/MK to get your free quote. They Shop. You Save.
Chapter: Chapter compares every Medicare plan nationwide to recommend the right coverage for you. Call them at (910) 375-5179 or visit https://chapter.com/kelly to get free, unbiased Medicare help. *Paid Partnership Chapter and its affiliates are not connected with or endorsed by any government entity or the federal Medicare program. Chapter Advisory, LLC represents Medicare Advantage HMO, PPO, and PFFS organizations and stand alone prescription drug plans that have a Medicare contract. Enrollment depends on the plan’s contract renewal. While we have a database of every Medicare plan nationwide and can help you to search among all plans, we have contracts with many but not all plans. As a result, we do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 50 organizations which offer 18,160 products nationwide. We search and recommend all plans, even those we don’t directly offer. You can contact a licensed Chapter agent to find out the number of products available in your specific area. Please contact https://Medicare.gov , 1-800-Medicare, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your options.
Q30 Sports Science: Head to https://Q30.com and use code MK for a FREE sleeve with your order
Follow MK True Crime on all social platforms:
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@MKTrueCrime
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/mktruecrime
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@mktruecrime
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61595217260540
Meet the MK True Crime hosts - MK True Crime Channel
More from MK True Crime
In The Well hosts Mark Geragos and Matt Murphy join the show to discuss Matt’s triumphant return after his surfing trip in Sumatra, the two lawyers finally get a chance to discuss the Cornell 7 case together, a prosecutor’s ethical standards for filing criminal charges in a sexual assault case, the different ethical north stars guiding prosecutors and defense attorneys, what the original investigation into Jane Doe’s allegations reveal, the misrepresentation of fraternities in wake of Cornell 7 case, the date rape education program Matt and his fraternity founded in college, the insanity of the wrong former fraternity president named in Jane Doe’s civil lawsuit, why the attorney general’s office is ill-equipped to handle sex crimes cases, why Letitia James ultimately may not prosecute the Cornell 7 case, Mark suggests James is already shopping for an independent prosecutor, and more.
The MK True Crime Show host Ashleigh Merchant is joined by former prosecutor and current host of "The Margaret McLean Show," Margaret McLean, to discuss updates in the Sandra Birchmore case, Margaret's experience being in the courtroom for the federal trial, the mounting evidence that suggests a cover-up of Birchmore’s murder by local authorities, the digital evidence that strongly suggests ex-cop Matthew Farwell was in Birchmore’s apartment at the time of her death, the evidence that Farwell and his twin brother Billy were both monitoring Sandra Birchmore before her death, the testimony of Birchmore’s hairstylist and her doctor, and later Ashleigh is joined by Jesse Weber, host of “Sidebar” and “Prime Crime” on the Law & Crime Network and host of “Jesse Weber Live” on NewsNation, to discuss the tragic death of actress Hayden Panettiere, the recently released 911 call audio, why the Drug Enforcement Administration is now involved in the ongoing investigation into her death, who could face what charges if investigators can find the source of the drugs she overdosed on, the latest status hearing in the murder case against singer D4vd, the debate about D4vd’s indigence and use of public defenders, the wrongful death lawsuit alleged victim Celeste Rivas Hernandez’s family has filed against him, and more.
Positively Legal hosts Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor join the show to discuss Katie Zacharia’s short-lived role as press secretary, whether she mislead the public about being a lawyer, how she could have handled the situation differently, Mark and Jonna then discuss the former president of the Cornell University fraternity where a then-undergraduate student alleged she was gang raped in 2024 was dropped Tuesday from her civil lawsuit after he was mistakenly identified as the chapter president at the time of the alleged attack, whether this mistake makes a difference in the court of public opinion, New York Governor Kathy Hochul’s comments during a debate last week that show she is biased about the Cornell 7 case, the holdout juror’s interview last week, his own words claiming he had “no reasonable doubt” that Lindsay Clancy was criminally responsible for the murder of her children, why holdout jurors are necessary to the legal process, and more.
The MK True Crime Show hosts Phil Holloway and Ashleigh Merchant join the program to discuss updates in the Sandra Birchmore trial, the news that Matthew Farwell’s mistresses will be allowed to testify, how their testimony relates to the notorious surveillance footage of Farwell in Birchmore’s apartment building the day prosecutors allege Birchmore died, some of the numerous messages investigators recovered between Farwell and Birchmore, updates in the murder trial of Virginia man Naresh Bhatt, the blood and DNA evidence prosecutors have presented so far, Mamta Bhatt’s last documented cellphone activity, the CCTV footage showing Naresh buying knives shortly before Mamta was reported missing, and later Phil and Ashleigh are joined by Managing Editor of Law&Crime and Court TV Cathy Russon to discuss her new show Court Chatter with Cathy Russon on Law&Crime+, the fatal abuse trial of Wisconsin man Timothy Hauschultz regarding the 2018 hypothermia death of his seven-year-old great-nephew Ethan Hauschultz, the testimony of Timothy’s stepson Damian Hauschultz, the nature of the “punishment” Ethan was carrying out when he died, other parties previously convicted in Ethan’s death, the latest pre-trial hearing in Alex Murdaugh’s retrial for the alleged double murder of his wife Maggie and his youngest son Paul, why Cathy refers to Judge Debra McCaslin as “Judge Mom,” the courtroom antics we’ve seen from both the defense and the prosecution, the mistake defense attorney Dick Harpootlian had to own up to regarding a polygraph test Murdaugh reportedly failed, what we can learn from the evidence issues raised by the defense so far, and more.
In The Well host Mark Geragos is joined by criminal defense attorney Alexandra Kazarian and LA Magazine contributor Lauren Conlin to discuss the latest Cornell 7 legal drama that unfolded on Wednesday, why Jane Doe’s attorney, Thomas Giuffra, filed a response accusing defense lawyers of selectively leaking confidential Cornell Title IX records to the press, why Giuffra attacked TMZ and Mark Geragos in the filing, Alexandra Kazarian analyzes the timeline in Jane Doe’s text messages, the selective roll out of the Cornell 7 IX report by Jane Doe’s legal team and major media outlets, the legal relevance of Jane Doe’s move to New York City, inside attorney Thomas Giuffra’s filing accusing Mark of undermining Jane Doe’s credibility, why Giuffra brings Diddy into the filing, whether Jane Doe has an emotional distress case, and much more.