Live From Mars

Lady Gaga’s "Mayhem" Album Review & Track-by-Track Breakdown (with Seth Betzler)

Live From Mars

Show Notes

Lady Gaga’s Mayhem Album Review & Track-by-Track Breakdown

Lady Gaga’s new album Mayhem is here, and we’re breaking it all down! In this episode of Live From Mars, I’m joined by Seth Betzler for a deep dive into Lady Gaga’s 2025 return to pop.

We dive into the road to this moment—how Chromatica left its mark, Gaga’s jazz era with Tony Bennett, the fallout from Joker 2, and the unexpected smash success of Die with a Smile. Plus, we unpack the Mayhem rollout: Did Disease truly serve as the “lead” single? How did Abracadabra’s massive Grammy premiere change the game? And why does the album’s grunge-inspired aesthetic not quite match the genre-blending sound Gaga delivered?

Then, it’s time for a track-by-track breakdown—analyzing every song, from the industrial grit of Disease and Perfect Celebrity to the euphoric highs of Vanish Into You and Zombie Boy. And of course, we wrap things up with Best, Worst, Fav—choosing the best song, the weakest track, and our personal favorites from Mayhem.

Is Mayhem a defining moment in Lady Gaga’s career, or just another unexpected pivot? Let’s talk about it.

🎧 Listen now and let us know your thoughts on Mayhem!

📲 Follow Alex: @vinylbymars on TikTok | Instagram 📲 Follow Seth: @dramakingvinyl on TikTok | Instagram, @dramakingbooks on TikTok | Instagram To provide feedback, please fill out this survey: http://bit.ly/livefrommars-survey Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from Live From Mars

May 11, 2026

Matt Hansen joins Live From Mars for an emotional deep dive into his debut album Orchid, the songwriting experiences that shaped it, and the realities of building a music career completely independently.

Feb 3, 2026

Subscribe on Substack for more Mars Music: https://vinylbymars.substack.com/

Jan 26, 2026

Subscribe on Substack: https://vinylbymars.substack.com

Jan 7, 2026

In this episode of Live From Mars, I sit down with John Stein, Head of Editorial at Spotify, to break down Spotify Wrapped 2025 and what the year in music actually sounded like.

Dec 22, 2025

Subscribe to my Substack for more pop music deep dives and unfiltered reactions: https://vinylbymars.substack.com

See all episodes →