Scary Horror Stories

The Meadow With a Boot and No Footprints: Lost at 9,400

Scary Horror Stories

Show Notes

The Meadow With a Boot and No Footprints: Lost at 9,400

A single hiking boot stood upright, unlaced and dry inside, in the center of a frozen meadow pool with no tracks in the mud from any direction-yet that boot was the first sign anyone had that Jessica Keller was missing. How did a right boot end up alone on ice while the person who wore it vanished into wind, temperature drops and unexplained scent termini?

In this episode, we follow the four-day search above the Caldera Creek corridor and the odd clues that kept pointing the wrong way, from surveillance of Jessica's Subaru to canine teams that stopped at an empty spot on Rim Flats. What caused two trained tracking dogs to refuse to move past a precise point in an open meadow?

Person: Jessica Keller Date: April 2006 (Wednesday April 5, 2006 - Thursday) Location: Caldera Creek corridor / Rim Flats / Rim Flats Status: Missing Event: Single right hiking boot found upright in frozen meadow pool

- Jessica Keller was 48 years old and employed as a billing coordinator at the Farren orthopedic clinic for 11 years. - She had delivered dinner every Thursday to her mother at Ponderosa Arms for four years without exception. - Surveillance recorded her Subaru entering the Rim Flats trailhead parking lot at 5:22 PM; there was no footage of it returning. - Wind at Rim Flats on Wednesday night reached sustained 19 mph, gusting to 31 mph, and temperature dropped to 28°F by 11:40 PM. - Two dog teams (bloodhound Hooper and Belgian Malinois Petra) independently stopped at the same unmarked point near the center of Rim Flats, logged as a scent terminus, with no physical disturbance.

To listen to this podcast ad-free and access premium episodes, try our subscription with a 14-day free trial at obomedia.com.

© 2026 OBOMEDIA. All rights reserved. This episode and its content (audio, text, and related materials) are the exclusive property of OBOMEDIA and are protected by applicable copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, editing, or commercial use, in whole or in part, without prior written permission from OBOMEDIA is prohibited. For permissions, licensing, and business inquiries: [email protected].

More from Scary Horror Stories

Oct 23, 2026

The Lone Bootprint North of Rimrock Tower

Oct 22, 2026

The Pink Boot on the Granite Shelf: What Amy Couldn't Explain

Oct 21, 2026

Signal Where Snow Shouldn't Be: The Trekking Pole in the Ledge

Oct 20, 2026

Dry Notebook in Unbroken Snow: Where Nancy Vanished from the Trail

Oct 19, 2026

She Climbed an Impossible Couloir - Found Alive, Stakes Unexplained

See all episodes →