The 42FM

Does the GAA have an AFL problem?

The 42FM

Show Notes

Declan Bogue joins Sinéad O’Carroll and Niall Kelly as the lure of Australia proves strong for many young footballers.

The GAA, says Sinead, have been ‘getting their knickers in a twist’ about the prospect of yet more talented players swapping Ireland for a life of sunshine, flat whites and professionalism in Melbourne and other Australian cities. But should they?

With Kobe McDonald signed up with St Kilda, and combines in Ireland attracting top talent, while AFL clubs continue to target successful U20 sides, what can be done? Not very much, suggest our panel, adding that a more pertinent question might be why would you even consider ways to prevent professional opportunities to young people?

Are suggestions of limiting the flow of players essentially illegal? And is the idea of compensating clubs or counties antithetical to the GAA’s amateur ethos?

And will the flow of players, in the men’s game at least, always be limited by the demand from Australia, where there are hundreds of thousands of players in the sport’s pyramid, most of them trained in the skills of the game from childhood? Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from The 42FM

Oct 20, 2026

Sinéad and Niall welcome Mark Horgan of the Second Captains/BBC podcast 'Where is George Gibney?' to reflect on the paedophile's criminal conviction and sentencing 33 years after he was first charged in a Dublin court.

Oct 14, 2026

Paul Howard joins Sinéad O’Carroll and Niall Kelly to talk about how sport would work in a united Ireland.

Oct 6, 2026

Sinead O’Carroll and Niall Kelly are joined by the much-admired sportswriter for a far-reaching chat.

Sep 29, 2026

Sinéad O’Carroll is joined by David Sneyd, who has returned from a tumultuous few days in Debrecen with the Ireland football team.

Sep 22, 2026

Ireland will play Israel twice in the coming weeks, despite widely articulated concern and protest over the fixtures. Niall Kelly and Sinead O’Carroll discuss the background to these games, how they came about, and why they will go ahead despite the misgivings of many supporters.

See all episodes →