Blunt Force Trauma

3 | All Muddled Up

Blunt Force Trauma

Show Notes

A single phone call changes everything. As we work to pinpoint exactly when Faithe’s family was told she was dead, the timeline begins to fracture in ways that are difficult to explain, and even harder to ignore.

As the known events of that night are broken down and tested against distance, sound, and witness accounts, a troubling pattern starts to emerge. On paper, the official version of events may be possible, but when placed against the full weight of the evidence, it begins to feel increasingly unlikely… and dangerously incomplete. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Blunt Force Trauma

Jun 3, 2026

As the conversation continues, Amanda, Kaitlynn and Casey press deeper into the details of Faithe’s final night, trying to separate grief from suspicion, memory from fact, and explanation from excuse.

Jun 3, 2026

Amanda, Kaitlynn and Casey sit down with the one person who may know more about those final hours than anyone else.

May 28, 2026

The investigation takes a darker turn when two anonymous callers share disturbing claims about Faithe’s death, a list of women marked for violence, and a town where fear seems to travel faster than truth.

May 12, 2026

The investigation takes a side step when Amanda shares shocking information about an assault - and the series of unfathomable events that followed, as she and Kaitlynn find themselves on the bumpy road toward accountability and justice for the second time in as many months.

May 4, 2026

The investigation of a new threat is thwarted by a disappearing witness as Amanda begins piecing together a profile on just who may have been behind the threatening phone call to her Aunt.

See all episodes →