Ruth Mac Fit Podcast

Episode 68: Not Another Diet: How to Escape All-or-Nothing Thinking

Ruth Mac Fit Podcast

Show Notes

If you’ve ever said “I’ll just do this 6-week plan and then get back to normal,” this one’s for you. Ruth unpacks why the structure of most diets keeps us stuck in all-or-nothing thinking and what to do instead. You’ll hear how to use calorie ranges (without turning numbers into “good” vs “bad”), why tracking isn’t a non-negotiable, and how tiny, realistic habits create results you can keep. We’ll talk maintenance vs fat-loss, false hope syndrome, push vs adapt, and why the No Crap Cake Method is built for real life in your 40s and beyond. Why short programs (6–12 weeks) quietly fuel the start–stop loop

How to set calorie ranges (and weekly averages) without falling into perfectionism

What real non-negotiables look like (hint: not tracking everything) and how to choose yours

The push/adapt mindset: when to go harder and when to hold steady

Why “optimal” advice isn’t everyday life and why transparency matters

The 4 pillars of the No Crap Cake Method: Less often, more enjoyable

Make choices, not reactions

No failure, only feedback

Make it fun, make it life

Pick one tiny non-negotiable you can do even on your busiest day (e.g., add protein to one meal, 5-minute walk/stretch, write 3 wins before bed). Do it daily. Notice how it changes how you feel. Join The No Crap Cake Method (coaching for women 40+ who are done with all-or-nothing) details at ruthmacfit.com

Say hi on Instagram: @ruthmacfit

Share your non-negotiable with Ruth...she loves hearing them!

More from Ruth Mac Fit Podcast

Oct 23, 2026

In this episode, I'm joined by Lauren Chiren, founder of Women of a Certain Stage, to talk about perimenopause, menopause and the workplace. We chat about Lauren's own experience of menopause, why so many women struggle in silence, the connection between ADHD and hormonal changes, and what employers can do to offer better support. We also explore your rights at work, how to advocate for yourself and why menopause doesn't have to mean the beginning of the end. It can be the start of something new. Connect with Lauren:- Instagram: @themenopausecoach Website: www.womenofacertainstage.com LinkedIn: Lauren Chiren Podcast: Women of a Certain Stage

Oct 16, 2026

In this episode, I’m talking about the space between diet culture and the anti-diet world, and why I think there’s a useful middle ground. We cover: why I don’t want women to become really good at dieting

Oct 9, 2026

Perimenopause: What Can Help You Feel More Like Yourself? A member asked whether we could hear something positive about perimenopause, and I thought that was a conversation worth having. In this episode, I’m sharing some changes I’ve noticed myself, what’s happening with our hormones, and how we can understand this stage without expecting the worst. We’ll also talk about practical ways to support ourselves through sleep, movement, strength training and food, alongside getting help when we need it. You don’t need to change everything. Take one or two ideas that feel realistic for you, and remember there’s still plenty to look forward to. The eye-movement and breathing exercise A little correction: it was Jimmy Fallon, rather than Jimmy Kimmel, who Andrew Huberman was speaking to. For those nights when you wake up and your mind starts racing, this is the exercise he suggested: Close your eyes and keep them closed throughout.

Sep 25, 2026

How useful is your smartwatch, and when does all that data start getting in the way? In this episode, I’m looking at my own relationship with tracking, from my first very chunky Garmin back in 2007 to watches and rings that now track our steps, sleep, recovery and readiness to train. I talk about where tracking can be useful, particularly when it helps us understand how much we’re actually moving, but also what can happen when a number starts to define what “enough” looks like. I share some of my own experiences with step targets, running without tracking, Polar telling me I was “detraining” after taking an easier day, and checking my Oura Ring before I’d even stopped to think about how I actually felt. I also look at some interesting research around activity trackers, sleep tracking and recovery scores. This isn’t about getting rid of your smartwatch. It’s about asking whether the information is helping you make decisions, or whether it’s becoming another thing to pass, fail or stress about. Find me online Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ruthmacfit/ Website: https://www.ruthmacfit.com/ Join the Ruth Mac Fit membership waitlist: https://www.ruthmacfit.com/wait-list

Sep 18, 2026

Protein powder: useful or unnecessary? How sore should you really be after training? If you're already quite lean but still have cellulite, is more fat loss actually the answer? In this episode, I'm answering some of your questions around protein, DOMS, recovery and body composition. We look at how much protein you actually need, why more soreness doesn't mean a better workout, how stress and perimenopause can affect recovery, and why reaching a lower weight isn't always the answer when what you really want is more muscle and shape. I also talk about the trap of looking at somebody else's calories, protein, steps or training and assuming their numbers should become yours. Links Join the Ruth Mac Fit waitlist: https://ruthmacfit.com/wait-list Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ruthmacfit/

See all episodes →