Social Currency with Sammi Cohen

Peloton: First Profit, the Spotify Deal and Why the Stock Still Fell

Social Currency with Sammi Cohen

Show Notes

For the first time in its history as a public company, Peloton turned a profit. After years of billion-dollar losses, the fitness brand posted $63 million in net income this fiscal year. Just three years ago, it was a punchline.

Today, Sammi unpacks how Peloton went from pandemic darling to cautionary tale and back again. She revisits the crash that wiped out $40 billion in market value, founder John Foley's exit, and the Sex and the City reboot that turned a Peloton bike into a plot device. Then, she breaks down the turnaround strategy led by CEO Peter Stern, the former Apple executive who built his career on subscriptions, not hardware.

Sammi walks through the bets that got Peloton back in the black: aggressive price increases and cost cuts, a viral ad campaign starring Heated Rivalry's Hudson Williams, a global partnership with Spotify, and a new push into commercial gyms. Plus, she explains why the stock dropped more than 11% on the day Peloton announced its historic profit, and what that says about whether Peloton is really back.

Follow Sammi Cohen on Instagram

Subscribe to the Social Currency newsletter

Here's What Sammi Covers Today:

00:00 Peloton's First Profitable Year

01:50 Partner Message - Mercury

02:50 From $50 Billion to Punchline

03:45 John Foley's Exit and the 87% Wipeout

04:15 The Pandemic Bubble Cautionary Tale

04:55 Enter Peter Stern, Peloton's Apple Hire

05:45 The Four-Pillar Turnaround Plan

06:15 Price Hikes and Cost Cuts

07:30 The Heated Rivalry Ad That Went Viral

08:15 The Spotify Partnership

08:58 Peloton's Commercial Gym Bet

09:55 The $63 Million Turnaround

10:25 Partner Message -Mercury

12:45 Why the Stock Fell Anyway

13:15 A Shrinking Subscriber Base

14:40 How to Show Social Currency Some Love

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Social Currency with Sammi Cohen

Oct 20, 2026

Mary Holland Nader spent five years managing money for ultra-high-net-worth clients at Deutsche Bank. Then she quit to film a reality show with her three sisters… and pitched a fintech company on camera.

Oct 13, 2026

What if kids could finish a full day of academics in just two hours? That’s the promise behind Alpha School, the AI-powered private school claiming its students learn 2.6 times faster than their peers and graduate with an average SAT score above 1470.

Oct 6, 2026

Bala started with $5,000, a sketch and a yoga class that wasn't hard enough. Today, the brand behind the bangles on every workout influencer's wrists is growing 50% year over year with just 12 full-time employees.

Sep 22, 2026

Nearly a billion people open Snapchat every month, and almost half a billion use it every single day. Fifteen years after Evan Spiegel and his co-founders launched the app, formerly known as Peekaboo, out of a Stanford dorm room, Snap is betting its next decade on something you wear on your face.

Sep 15, 2026

How does a scrappy startup beat Amazon when Amazon copies your product, undercuts your price and slaps its own name on it? According to Square co-founder Jim McKelvey, you don't. Except, once in a while, someone does.

See all episodes →