Creepy Tales Radio - Old Time Radio Horror

Night Man - Suspense | 07/26/1959 (Ep812)

Creepy Tales Radio - Old Time Radio Horror

Summary

A woman named Miss Rhodes expresses her deep fear to Warden Graves, believing that Tom Nixon, a man convicted of murdering her mother, has escaped from prison and is now stalking her. She recounts a chilling encounter with a new elevator operator who bears an uncanny resemblance to Nixon, leading her to believe he is out for revenge after ten years of living in fear since his conviction.

Warden Graves attempts to reassure her by revealing that Nixon is actually dead, having passed away in prison. He shows her evidence, including a photograph and personal belongings, to confirm that the man she saw is not Nixon. Despite this, Miss Rhodes struggles to reconcile her fear with the evidence presented, convinced that the resemblance is too strong to ignore.

As the tension escalates, the elevator they are in suddenly gets stuck, plunging them into darkness. In a panic, Miss Rhodes confesses to having framed Nixon for her mother's murder, revealing her guilt and the psychological torment she has endured. The situation takes a twist when the elevator operator, who is not Nixon, hints at knowing her secret, leaving her in a state of terror as she grapples with her past actions.

Show Notes

Suspense was one of the most popular and successful radio series during it's run of over 900 episodes, spanning 1940-1962. Guest stars included Orson Welles, Frank Sinatra, Lucille Ball, Agnes Moorehead, Marlene Dietrich and Humphrey Bogart. The plots were mostly engaging crime dramas, science fiction and some horror - usually with a surprise ending.

Hope you enjoy this episode of Suspense! Find all our OTR radio stations and podcasts at theaterofthemind-otr.com - Audio Credit: The Old Time Radio Researchers Group. - All Podcasts @ Spreaker | Apple | YouTube | Spotify | Amazon | iHeart

More from Creepy Tales Radio - Old Time Radio Horror

Oct 21, 2026

The Whistler was a suspenseful mystery anthology that ran from 1942-1955. A character known only as the Whistler was the host and narrator of the tales, which focused on crime and fate and had a suspenseful and eerie tone, always ending with a twist. The Whistler was later adapted to television.

Oct 20, 2026

Lights Out was one of the premier American old time radio programs and was devoted primarily to horror and the supernatural. Created by Wyllis Cooper and then eventually taken over by Arch Oboler, versions of Lights Out aired on different networks, at various times, from January 3, 1934 to the summer of 1947 and the series eventually made the transition to television.

Oct 19, 2026

The Shadow was a fictional character created by American magazine publishers Street & Smith and writer Walter B. Gibson. He was an invincible crime fighter who possessed many gifts which enabled him to overcome any enemy. In addition to his great strength, he defied gravity, spoke any language, unraveled any codes and most notably, he became invisible with his ability to "cloud men's minds." The Shadow was originally created to be a mysterious radio show narrator but developed into a distinct literary character. The Shadow has been adapted in many forms of media, such as American comic books, comic strips, serials, video games, and at least five feature films.

Oct 18, 2026

Suspense was one of the most popular and successful radio series during it's run of over 900 episodes, spanning 1940-1962. Guest stars included Orson Welles, Frank Sinatra, Lucille Ball, Agnes Moorehead, Marlene Dietrich and Humphrey Bogart. The plots were mostly engaging crime dramas, science fiction and some horror - usually with a surprise ending.

Oct 17, 2026

The Whistler was a suspenseful mystery anthology that ran from 1942-1955. A character known only as the Whistler was the host and narrator of the tales, which focused on crime and fate and had a suspenseful and eerie tone, always ending with a twist. The Whistler was later adapted to television.

See all episodes →