Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

S5 E21 - Wedding Eve

Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

Show Notes

This podcast covers New Girl Season 5, Episode 21, Wedding Eve, which originally aired on May 10, 2016 and was written by Nina Pedrad & Kim Rosenstock and directed by Trent O'Donnell.

Here’s a quick recap of the episode: Jess and Nick pull off an exceptional rehearsal dinner in the loft, but then in typical New Girl fashion, chaos ensues. Jess thinks Sam is going to propose to her prompting an impromptu game of True American so that she can avoid him.

This episode got a 7.5/10 rating from Kritika and a 9/10 from Kelly and we both had the same favorite character: Winston!

Episode Sections: (00:00) Welcome (1:30) Episode Recap: Jess is Getting Engaged? (27:16) Episode Recap: Schmidt’s Vows (35:25) Episode Recap: Winston & Aly (40:44) Schmidtism (42:23) Pop Culture (47:25) Guest Stars (49:41) Trivia & Fun Facts + Bear Hunt (53:59) Rating & Favorite Character (57:30) Spoilers

While not discussed in the podcast, we noted other references in this episode including: Justin Trudeau - Jess jokingly prepared for an emergency escape to Canada for her and Cece by gathering their passports and pictures of Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

Rick Santorum - While struggling to remember his lost wedding vows, Schmidt recalled starting a sentence with a reference to politician Rick Santorum.

James Bond - When listing what he believes are the only seven types of stories in existence, Nick included James Bond as a specific genre.

During the game of True American, the loft referred to the following references:

Michelle [Obama]

Mary Todd Lincoln

Jackie O

Eleanor [Roosevelt]

Nancy Reagan

Bay of Pigs

Franklin D. Roosevelt

[Mount] Rushmore

Hillary [Clinton]

Jenna [Bush Hager]

Skull and Bones

Seneca Falls Convention

Iron Curtain - To decide who would get Coach on their team, Winston and Cece suggested going "behind the iron curtain" to settle the dispute.

"Changes" - Langhorne Slim & The Law - This song by Langhorne Slim & The Law played during the final moments of the episode.

Thanks for listening and stay tuned for Episode 21 Bonus Episode!

Music: "Hotshot” by ⁠scottholmesmusic.com⁠ Follow us on ⁠Instagram⁠ or email us at ⁠[email protected]⁠! Website: ⁠https://smallscreenchatter.com/⁠

More from Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

Oct 19, 2026

Hey everyone! It’s Kritika and Kelly, your long-distance besties and hosts of Who’s That Girl?—a ‘New Girl’ podcast!

Sep 7, 2026

This podcast covers a recap of the fifth season of New Girl. We’re your hosts, Kelly and Kritika, and we originally met through work but now we consider ourselves long distance best friends. We’ve bonded over our love of TV and brought you this podcast to recap one of our favorite shows -- New Girl.

Jul 27, 2026

This podcast covers our honest book review for “Who's That Girl: The Untold, Definitive History of New Girl” written by Thea Glassman.

Jul 20, 2026

This podcast covers our bonus content for New Girl Season 5, Episode 22, Landing Gear where we dive into our ‘Most Likely To’ picks and we also answer some of your listener questions.

Jul 13, 2026

This podcast covers New Girl Season 5, Episode 22, Landing Gear, which originally aired on May 10, 2016 and was written by Luvh Rakhe and directed by Erin O'Malley.

See all episodes →