The Good, The Bad & The Football

Scholes & Butt On Arteta's Biggest Problem, Tottenham's Crisis & Tuchel's England Squad!

The Good, The Bad & The Football

Show Notes

The Good, The Bad & The Football is back with another brilliant episode. Paul, Nicky and Paddy kick things off with Manchester City’s League Cup win over Arsenal, with Scholesy calling it a “victory for football”. But where did it go wrong for Arsenal? Scholesy argues that Kepa Arrizabalaga’s mistake distracted from just how poor Arsenal were overall and questions whether they have the flair to play expansive football, while Nicky believes the Gunners are simply panicking in their pursuit of a trophy. They also reflect on a brilliant day for Nico O'Reilly, but how did his 21st birthday really compare to Paddy’s?

Attention then turns to Tottenham Hotspur’s 3-0 defeat to Nottingham Forest, with Nicky suggesting Spurs fans made the occasion too big before a ball was kicked. The lads debate whether Igor Tudor has come in too hard on the squad, and discuss how Tottenham can still salvage their season, but who could they turn to to drag them away from trouble. Nicky reflects on how Kevin Keegan’s return once revitalised Newcastle United, while they weigh up whether Liam Rosenior was fortunate to land the Chelsea job and if Frank Lampard could one day return.

There’s a chat on the latest England squad. The lads question the absence of Danny Welbeck and Ollie Watkins, and tackle why Trent Alexander-Arnold has fallen from favour, while Scholesy raises concerns about the form of England’s No.10s, including Cole Palmer, Phil Foden and Jude Bellingham, while also revealing which one of himself, Steven Gerrard and Lampard he thinks Thomas Tuchel would have dropped back in the day.

Finally, things descend into chaos as the lads attempt to name their Mount Rushmore of Premier League legends. Paddy goes for a full English, Scholesy leans heavily towards Manchester United… and it all gets very heated.

If you want to ask the guys anything about football email them at: [email protected] The Good, The Bad & The Football:YouTube: www.youtube.com/@goodbadfootballpodInstagram: @goodbadfootballpodX/Twitter: @goodbadftblpodTikTok: goodbadfootballpodFacebook: www.facebook.com/goodbadfootballpod

Enter for the chance to win two tickets to Man United vs Liverpool + flights & accommodation 👉 www.thatprizeguy.co.uk

00:00 - Arsenal 0-2 Man City

23:50 - Fergie’s Teamtalks

29:45 - Win tickets to Man United vs Liverpool

34:10 - Tottenham In Crisis!

43:30 - Liam Rosenior

48:00 - England Squad Reaction

54:50 - Premier League Mount Rushmore Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Good, The Bad & The Football

Oct 19, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy welcome Gordon Strachan onto the show to discuss the genius of Sir Alex Ferguson and reflect on a difficult week for Manchester United following Lisandro Martinez's explosive post-match interview.

Oct 12, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy discuss the fallout from Manchester City's 3-0 win at Anfield, despite the talk of Liverpool's intense atmosphere in the build-up and Manchester United's disappointing 1-1 draw with Tottenham in the Premier League.

Sep 29, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy are joined by Mark Ogden to dissect the reports that Manchester City have been found guilty of 114 charges in their court case against the Premier League. What repercussions could they face? What does it mean for their legacy?

Sep 21, 2026

Paul, Nicky & Paddy reflect on Manchester United's drab 1-1 draw with Fulham, as well as Arsenal and Chelsea's surprise defeats.

See all episodes →