The Ellen Fisher Podcast

Plant-Based vs Carnivore DEBATE: Which Diet is Better for Longevity? Simon Hill vs Dr. Robert Kiltz

The Ellen Fisher Podcast

Show Notes

Two Passionate experts debate nutrition.

Simon Hill is a physiotherapist and nutrition scientist, and host of The Proof Podcast, with a best selling book The Proof is in the Plants. With a masters degree in nutrition, he has a healthy obsession with nutritional science. He began his career interested in the physiology and anatomy related to optimal athletic performance. Then, encouraged by his Dad’s heart attack, he turned his attention to nutrition’s role in preventing disease and optimizing health. Dr Robert Kiltz is a Diplomat of the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Fellowship trained and Board Certified in Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility. He is the Founder and Director of CNY Fertility, one of the largest and most innovative fertility practices in the country, and a thought leader in the keto carnivore movement. Dr. Kiltz believes that an animal-based diet dramatically improves mental clarity, fertility, and health Robert and Simon have very different perspectives on the hierarchy of evidence. Will they be able to see eye to eye on anything?

SPONSORS:

Cymbiotika: Enter code ELLEN for 20% off + free shipping on your subscription order

OSEA: EARLY BLACK FRIDAY IS COMING on 11/22. Shop and earn up to 4 free gifts with a purchase of $125+ during OSEA’s early black friday offer from 11/22 -11/25. Use my code for an additional 10% off starting 11/22.

Sayu: get 15% off with code ELLEN

Anima Mundi Herbals: Get 20% off with my code ELLENFISHER20

WHERE TO FIND DR KILTZ

website

Instagram

YouTube

WHERE TO FIND SIMON

website

The Proof Podcast

Instagram

WHERE TO FIND ME

The Empowered Pregnancy & Birth course

My ebooks

My instagram

Elevate your videos with record-label quality music from Musicbed

More from The Ellen Fisher Podcast

Mar 24, 2026

In this episode of The Ellen Fisher Podcast, I sit down with Kayde Mason and Katy Faust for a raw debate on IVF, surrogacy, and donor conception—are these modern paths to parenthood crossing ethical lines, or worth celebrating?

Mar 10, 2026

In this episode, I sit down with filmmaker Benjamin Nolot, who is the founder and CEO of Exodus Cry, a non profit fighting to end trafficking and sexual exploitation. We discuss the rapidly changing world of commercial sexual exploitation and the rise of platforms like OnlyFans, the emergence of AI-generated pornography, and how these technologies are reshaping cultural attitudes toward sex, intimacy, and human dignity. Benjamin also shares insights from his latest documentary, Buying Her, which exposes the often-ignored demand side of the sex trade: the men who purchase sex.

Feb 24, 2026

In this episode, I sit down with debt elimination expert and The Ramsey Show co-host Jade Warshaw to unpack a truth most people never hear: your money problem isn’t about your income — it’s about your emotions. Jade shares her own journey from financial stress and overwhelm to becoming debt-free, and the rock-bottom moment that forced her to confront the beliefs and behaviors driving her spending. We talk about why making more money rarely fixes what’s actually broken, the biggest lie keeping families financially stuck, and why so many high-income earners are still drowning in debt.

Jan 26, 2026

Registration for Kim Anami’s signature Salon, Vaginal Kung Fu, is open NOW through Feb 5th!

See all episodes →