New Politics: Australian Politics, News, Analysis & Commentary

The Royal Commission and silencing the critics of Israel

New Politics: Australian Politics, News, Analysis & Commentary

Show Notes

Australia’s Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion was created to confront genuine antisemitism, but is it instead silencing criticism of Israel and deepening division? We examine the uneven treatment of Zionist, progressive Jewish and pro-Palestinian witnesses; Jillian Segal’s proposals for scrutinising ABC and SBS coverage; pressure to adopt the controversial IHRA definition of antisemitism; and the threat to free speech, editorial independence and legitimate debate about Israel, Palestine and Gaza. Antisemitism must be confronted, but selectively testing evidence and redefining political dissent as prejudice will not strengthen social cohesion – it will erode public confidence and create even greater division. #AUSPOL Subscribe to New Politics for weekly briefings and full analysis: www.newpolitics.com.au Support New Politics: Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/newpolitics Substack: https://newpolitics.substack.com Song listing: ‘La Femme d’Argent’, AIR.

More from New Politics: Australian Politics, News, Analysis & Commentary

Oct 22, 2026

The alleged attack on independent MP Helen Haines in Wangaratta raises urgent questions about political violence in Australia, the safety of elected representatives and the health of Australian democracy. With the motive still under investigation, we examine how partisan blame and media framing can obscure the facts, while intimidation threatens political participation, particularly for women in politics. How can Australia protect its MPs while keeping them accessible to the communities they represent – and prevent political hostility from undermining democratic debate? #AusPol

Oct 18, 2026

Donald Trump’s cancelled plan to livestream Nidal Hasan’s execution raises disturbing questions about state violence, political spectacle and Australia’s willingness to challenge its closest ally. We examine Pete Hegseth’s proposal to turn capital punishment into online entertainment, Anthony Albanese’s belated condemnation, and the credibility of Australian human rights diplomacy when AUKUS, critical minerals and the US–Australia alliance complicate the response. If Australia really does opposes the death penalty, should its opposition to it really depend on who pulls the trigger? #AusPol

Oct 17, 2026

Australia champions international law, but where does it draw the line when human rights collide with defence contracts and strategic alliances? Labor and the Coalition’s decision to block a Senate inquiry into the Red Lines Package raises serious questions about Australian weapons exports, investments and trade linked to genocide, war crimes and illegal occupation. With Israel’s war in Gaza bringing the global F-35 supply chain and trade with illegal settlements into focus, we examine whether the Albanese government will support enforceable safeguards – or leave Australia’s human rights commitments subject to commercial and diplomatic convenience. #AusPol

Oct 16, 2026

Who holds power in the Blue Mountains—and whose interests come first? Ahead of the NSW election, we speak with NSW Greens candidate Luciana Carusi about PFAS water contamination, housing affordability, climate policy and the gap between community consultation and genuine influence. The former finance professional turned climate activist challenges coal and gas expansion, makes the case for public housing and essential services, and questions government priorities amid the cost-of-living crisis. From local development to Palestine and Gaza, this conversation examines political accountability and how communities can reclaim a meaningful say in their future. #AusPol #NSWGreens

Oct 15, 2026

Donald Trump’s sanctions against the International Criminal Court, Israel’s alleged war crimes in Gaza and controversy surrounding Navi Pillay and the Nobel Peace Prize expose the hypocrisy of a rules-based international order that shields powerful nations from accountability. Anthony Albanese and Penny Wong champion international law, yet Australia remains reluctant to challenge Washington and Benjamin Netanyahu. Has Australian foreign policy confused loyalty to the United States with national interest, and can the Albanese government defend international justice while accommodating those accused of undermining it? #AusPol

See all episodes →