Smart Podcast, Trashy Books: A Romance Novel Podcast

734. Finding Fire Island with Jess Rothschild

Smart Podcast, Trashy Books: A Romance Novel Podcast

Show Notes

Jess Rothschild is a podcaster and journalist, one of the founding writers at Autostraddle, and her latest project is a documentary podcast called Finding Fire Island, about the history of Fire Island, Cherry Grove, and the Pines. Her prior work includes The Cult of Soul Cycle, and I love BOTH of these productions. Jess has been writing online longer than I have, and we talk about internet history, the process of making a podcast documentary, and what it’s like to have all your neighbors tell their most juicy, gossipy stories to you. For work.

Finding Fire Island is a unique historical record, and I hope you’ll listen or watch.

Please be advised that you can’t talk about gay history in the US without talking about the AIDS epidemic and the loss of so many people, so this episode is a little poignant at times.

You can find Jess Rothschild on Instagram @JessXNYC.

Links ahoy!

Finding Fire Island The Cult of Body and Soul Hulu – Black Twitter: A People’s History Hot Takes and Deep Dives – Jess’s podcast Caitlin Whyte – Jess’s Sound Designer Them Autostraddle Dads & Daddies Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from Smart Podcast, Trashy Books: A Romance Novel Podcast

Oct 16, 2026

By listener request! My guest today is author and professor Jodi McAlister. You might remember Jodi from her appearance in episode 626 when we talked about her Marry Me Juliet trilogy, set within a fictional version of The Bachelor.

Oct 9, 2026

We’re going back to 2007 to take a look at the new releases in Romantic Times Magazine, and we’re so glad you’re joining us! We’ve got kooky books, taxidermy, chick lit, and a new entry into the character name hall of fame. Strap in, it’s getting weird.

Oct 2, 2026

Adib Khorram’s new book, Isn’t He Romantic, is out this week, so of course I wanted to ask many questions about it.

Sep 25, 2026

We’re back in the time machine to check out the ads and features from the February 2012 issue of Romantic Times.

Sep 18, 2026

My guest this week is Dylan Allen, and Lucy Wilson-Tagoe, who are conveniently the same person. Dylan Allen is a bestselling author of contemporary romance, while Lucy Wilson-Tagoe’s newest book To Catch a Sinner, is out now.

See all episodes →