Scary Story Podcast

On Those Nights, I Wished to Come Back

Scary Story Podcast

Show Notes

A quiet beach. A relationship on the edge. And an eerie story that keeps circling around in your head. After being left alone one night, a woman finds herself drawn to the shoreline, where the ocean and sky blur into nothing. But she’s not alone for long. A strange girl appears, knowing too much, saying things she shouldn’t… and slowly revealing a truth far more unsettling than being abandoned. This is a short scary story about guilt, identity, and the moment you realize you might already be disappearing. You can get these ad-free through ScaryPlus.com free for 14 days, then 4.99 per month. Cancel anytime. Find out more about Scary Story Podcast on ScaryStoryPodcast.com Edwin is on TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook as @edwincov Email at [email protected]

More from Scary Story Podcast

Oct 10, 2026

Sometimes we don't know why we fear the places we live in. In these scary stories, we explore hauntings in our homes. In the first story, "Silhouettes" we hear from a person who experiences moving figures in the walls that eventually come to life. In the second, "Your House is Haunted", a young boy knocks on the door with a solid warning: be careful, your house is haunted. And as our protagonists find out, our mind has to be open in order to take the signs seriously, or we risk suffering the consequences. You can get these ad-free through ScaryPlus.com free for 14 days, then 4.99 per month. Cancel anytime. Find out more about Scary Story Podcast on ScaryStoryPodcast.com Edwin is on TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook as @edwincov Email at [email protected]

Sep 23, 2026

A scary story about two brothers who discover a late night show called "Maggie's Box of Secrets" and begin to wonder what it could mean and how it ties into the strange phenomena going on in their home. The show tells them cautionary tales about living out in the woods and how to prepare for strange encounters, but something about the entire thing feels.... off. You can get these ad-free through ScaryPlus.com free for 14 days, then 4.99 per month. Cancel anytime. Find out more about Scary Story Podcast on ScaryStoryPodcast.com Edwin is on TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook as @edwincov Email at [email protected]

Sep 15, 2026

Some would say it's the devil, right?

Sep 8, 2026

In this scary story, a struggling family always has dark memories about wasting food. Long ago, they used to wish for food and would be willing to do almost anything for it. Well, not anything.

Sep 1, 2026

What if a person you remember was never there? These scary stories are about portraits, memories that we have that carry something else along with them: fear. In the first creepy story, we hear about a girl who describes her friends and the things they used to do together, but no one else can remember her. In the second scary story, we have a portrait that was gifted at a tianguis (a swapmeet), but it ended up taking a "life" of it's own. If you like taking things from strangers, this is going to make you think twice. Stories by Edwin Covarrubias (@edwincov) Follow us on social media as @scarypod More at ScaryStoryPodcast.com

See all episodes →