The Commonweal Podcast

Ep. 165 - Is Anti-Vaxx Really Anti-Science?

The Commonweal Podcast

Show Notes

Vaccines have encountered resistance ever since they were invented in the late eighteenth century.

But vaccine skepticism has never been as vocal—or as widespread—as it has become in the United States in recent years.

Much of that has to do with the policies of the Trump administration, in particular Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., whose drastic changes at the CDC have reversed decades of American vaccination policy.

But what explains such broad receptivity to vaccine skepticism among wide swaths of Americans?

On this episode, Commonweal associate editor Regina Munch speaks with Kiera Ganga Kieffer, a professor of religious studies at Fairfield University. Her new book, Unvaccinated Under God, offers a provocative reading of the history of vaccine hesitancy in America.

Anti-vaccination beliefs are less a matter of scientific misinformation, Kieffer argues, than forms of religious expression, in which vaccines themselves become proxies for broader existential concerns about justice and morality.

For further reading:

Regina Munch on Kennedy’s crusade against vaccination

Michael Peppard on persuading anti-vaxxers during the pandemic

M. Anthony Mills on rebuilding America’s scientific infrastructure

More from The Commonweal Podcast

Oct 16, 2026

The field of history is under fire these days, and not just from conservatives.

Oct 2, 2026

Readers of Commonweal and beyond will likely recognize Lawrence Joseph, the author of many books of poetry and prose, and whose work has often appeared in the pages of our magazine.

Sep 17, 2026

By now, many of us are familiar with the realities of the Trump administration’s violent campaign of mass deportations. But how often do we listen to the stories of some of the most vulnerable victims—young children and teenagers separated from their families?

Aug 27, 2026

What happens when we read the Bible? Why do we read it? What does it do to us?

Aug 5, 2026

Debates over artificial intelligence tend to vacillate between the poles of blustery optimism and spiraling despair, with AI boosters making stratospheric claims for the technology just as critics vociferously denounce its capacity for disruption.

See all episodes →