Episode 4

Kim interviews Fred Lamb and takes a fresh look at the case.

Kim takes stock of the evidence against Fred Lamb and gets to the bottom of the stories she’s heard about him — including one from his wife of more than 30 years.

Kim examines the bizarre interrogation that led to Fred Lamb’s arrest.

Kim talks to someone who confessed to Shelli’s murder from a jail in Arizona.

Kim heads to Laramie and hears two very different versions of the case against Fred Lamb.