The Murder Men

How They Finally Caught the Gilgo Beach Killer | Rex Heuermann

The Murder Men

Show Notes

Follow us on all socials!⁣

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/murdermenpod/⁣

TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@murdermenpod⁣

Email us here - [email protected]⁣

⁣

Subscribe to our Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/0kp21jdbRjVgzdC1mchji1?si=662b92f9dc854f39⁣

⁣

Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down the decades-long Gilgo Beach serial killer case, from the victims and investigative failures to the DNA, digital evidence, and overlooked clues that finally led authorities to a suspect.⁣

⁣

Chapters:⁣

00:00 - Introduction to the Gilgo Beach Case ️⁣

02:37 - Background on Rex Huerman and His Double Life⁣

09:09 - Victimology and Modus Operandi ⁣

15:08 - The Early 2000s Unalivings ⁣

17:53 - MO, Taunting Calls, and Forensics Sloppiness⁣

24:08 - Gilgo Beach Discoveries and Unidentified Victims⁣

30:09 - Soundproof Room Horror⁣

31:21 - Urinal Story ️⁣

32:24 - Green River Case & Investigation Breakthrough ️‍️⁣

45:09 - Evidence & Surveillance ️‍️⁣

47:26 - DNA, Forensics & Hazmat Jokes⁣

54:16 - Arrest, Charges & Guilty Plea ️⁣

1:00:13 - Confession and Plea Discussion⁣

1:02:10 - Possibility of Additional Victims and Prison Conditions ️‍️ Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Murder Men

Oct 20, 2026

Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell investigate the case of Richard Andrews, a Washington grandfather whose disappearance leads detectives to uncover troubling family secrets, suspicious behavior, and conflicting accounts.⁣

Oct 17, 2026

Taking care of your health just got easier – start here with Zocdoc: https://zocdoc.com/murdermen #sponsored⁣

Oct 13, 2026

Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell break down the disturbing cases of Lisa Montgomery and Taylor Parker, two women whose elaborate pregnancy deceptions led to shocking crimes, and examine the investigations, motives, and legal questions surrounding their cases.⁣

Oct 10, 2026

Matt Cox and Johnny Mitchell examine the Atlanta Child Murders case, exploring Wayne Williams’ background, the investigation, and the evidence surrounding his involvement. The Murder Men debate his guilt and the questions that continue to surround the case decades later.⁣

Oct 6, 2026

Download the Kalshi app at https://kalshi.com/ and use code MEN to get $10 when you trade $10. ⁣

See all episodes →