Summary
A recent analysis reveals the complexities surrounding the effectiveness of digital advertising, particularly focusing on the concept of "clicks" as a measure of success. The discussion centers on a significant experiment conducted by eBay in 2012, where the company halted paid search ads in a third of the U.S. markets for 60 days. The results showed a 41% drop in paid search clicks, yet total sales remained largely unchanged, suggesting that many clicks were merely capturing existing demand rather than generating new sales.
The conversation delves into the evolution of the click metric, tracing its transformation from a simple log entry indicating a file transfer to a powerful metric that advertisers rely on for measuring success. This shift, driven by changes in how ads are sold and attributed, raises questions about the true value of clicks. The hosts argue that the advertising industry has become complicit in overvaluing clicks, often ignoring the underlying complexities of consumer behavior and the true impact of advertising on brand awareness and sales.
As the discussion unfolds, the hosts identify various "suspects" in the decline of the click's credibility, including advertising platforms, last-click attribution models, and marketers themselves. They emphasize the need for a critical reassessment of how advertising effectiveness is measured, advocating for a more nuanced understanding of metrics that truly reflect consumer engagement and brand impact. The episode concludes with a call to action for marketers to push back against simplistic metrics and to seek more comprehensive evaluations of their advertising strategies.
Show Notes
Send us Fan Mail Marketing runs on comfort blankets. The Sharp Cut cuts them up to see what's inside. This week, we did it as a murder mystery. The victim: the click. Once upon a time a click was one honest fact, a machine noting that a file left a building. Over eleven years it got poisoned, dose by dose, until it was taking credit for sales it never caused. The body: in 2012, eBay turned off roughly $51M in paid search across a third of the US, with matched control markets. Scored the way a...
More from Sleeping Barber - A Marketing Podcast
Send us Fan Mail Marketing science says buyer behaviour barely moves. Futurists sell the opposite: change, disruption, the thing nobody saw coming. Can both be true? Marc and Vassilis brought in someone who can referee it. Jo Lepore built the foresight function inside Mars Wrigley and then McDonald’s, co-founded a network for people doing that work at some of the world’s biggest companies, and now leads foresight at Dig Insights. She also hosts the podcast Looking Outside. Her starting point ...
Send us Fan Mail Marketing runs on comfort blankets. The Sharp Cut cuts them up to see what’s inside. This week, with Black Friday five weeks out and someone already writing the 40% off email: the idea that a discount wins you new business. Here’s the spine. A discount rents you this week’s sales, mostly from your own customers. When the price goes back up, the rental’s over. So every promotion has to pay for itself while it’s running. This week: → Who actually buys on the deal. Ehrenberg-Ba...
Send us Fan Mail Marc and V are back with the Barber’s Brief: the good, the bad, and the overhyped from the last couple of weeks, with data, a few opinions, and Great Creative getting the last word. This week: → Apple built itself a kill switch for ad tech. iOS 26’s Safari can quietly block hundreds of identity and data vendors, the list lives in a private repo, and only Apple knows the rules. Everyone’s calling it a privacy story. It’s a power story, and the real lesson is one we keep coming...
Send us Fan Mail Everybody in this industry is arguing about what AI does to an agency. Almost all of it is agencies talking to themselves about their own cost structure. Clients are asking something else entirely. So Marc and V put the real question to two of the people growing Canada’s agency business while the ground moves under it: if you are not selling hours, what are you selling? Mélanie Dunn is President of Plus Company Canada and CEO of Cossette. Karine Courtemanche is EVP of Plus Co...
Send us Fan Mail Marketing runs on comfort blankets. The Sharp Cut cuts them up to see what's inside. This week: brand love. Start with motorcycles. In 2015, the happiest owners in the entire category rode Victory, ahead of Harley. Two years later, Polaris shut Victory down. The happiest customers in the category could not keep the brand alive. That should bother anyone who spent a career being told marketing's job is to make people love you. So Marc and V take the believers at their word and...