Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

S5 E3 - Jury Duty

Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

Show Notes

This podcast covers New Girl Season 5, Episode 3, Jury Duty, which originally aired on January 19, 2016 and was written by Josh Malmuth & Nina Pedrad and directed by Trent O’Donnell.

Here’s a quick recap of the episode: Now that Cece and Schmidt are engaged, Cece has been spending more time at the loft and it’s starting to bother Nick. The loft is looking to Jess for guidance on how to handle the situation, but she has Jury Duty and is quite excited about fulfilling her civic duty.

This episode got a 6.5/10 rating from Kritika whose favorite character was Schmidt and Kelly rated this episode an 8/10 and her favorite character was Jess!

Episode Sections: (00:00) Welcome (01:37) Episode Recap: Fighting at Home (23:50) Episode Recap: Jess at Jury Duty (31:34) Episode Recap: Jess Comes Home (35:53) Schmidtism (37:34) Pop Culture (42:17) Guest Stars (44:27) Trivia & Fun Facts + Bear Hunt (51:59) Rating & Favorite Character (55:46) Spoilers

While not discussed in the podcast, we noted other references in this episode including: Arnold Schwarzanegger - Not everyone liked the Dogs Playing Poker poster that Winston wanted to hang on the wall and Schmidt mentioned he’d, “rather see a painting Of Arnold Schwarzenegger, mid-coitus. Just straight up doing it.”

The Pope - Schmidt kissed Nick on the head because he was happy and the guys questioned why Schmidt acts like the Pope when he’s happy.

Secretariat - Nick felt like he was living with the horse, Secretariat, because Cece left a pile of uneaten carrots strewn across the couch.

President Barack Obama - When in the court building, Jess speaks to a picture of Barack Obama who was the U.S. President at the time.

[Vladimir] Putin - Schmidt mentioned they couldn’t go to Cece’s apartment because Nadia’s baby would scream. Jess mentioned she had heard a Russian child scream in her “Putin nightmare”.

Rent / “Seasons of Love” - One of the tips left in the bowl from Jess was to "Tell Schmidt not to sing 'Rent' in the shower. We're in a drought." Schmidt then tried to sing the song “Seasons of Love” from the musical with the wrong words.

Thanks for listening and stay tuned for Episode 3 Bonus Episode!

Music: "Hotshot” by ⁠scottholmesmusic.com⁠ Follow us on ⁠Instagram⁠ or email us at ⁠[email protected]⁠! Website: ⁠https://smallscreenchatter.com/⁠

More from Who's That Girl? A 'New Girl' Podcast

Oct 19, 2026

Hey everyone! It’s Kritika and Kelly, your long-distance besties and hosts of Who’s That Girl?—a ‘New Girl’ podcast!

Sep 7, 2026

This podcast covers a recap of the fifth season of New Girl. We’re your hosts, Kelly and Kritika, and we originally met through work but now we consider ourselves long distance best friends. We’ve bonded over our love of TV and brought you this podcast to recap one of our favorite shows -- New Girl.

Jul 27, 2026

This podcast covers our honest book review for “Who's That Girl: The Untold, Definitive History of New Girl” written by Thea Glassman.

Jul 20, 2026

This podcast covers our bonus content for New Girl Season 5, Episode 22, Landing Gear where we dive into our ‘Most Likely To’ picks and we also answer some of your listener questions.

Jul 13, 2026

This podcast covers New Girl Season 5, Episode 22, Landing Gear, which originally aired on May 10, 2016 and was written by Luvh Rakhe and directed by Erin O'Malley.

See all episodes →