Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Ep 2 Recap

Dancing with the Stars Season 35 Premiere Night 2 Recap

Also available on YouTube.

Dancing with the Stars returns for the second night of its 35th season, and Matt Liguori and Sasha Joseph break down every glittery step as the women make their ballroom debut. With five hours of content in the opening week and a jam-packed cast, the co-hosts dive into routines, judge banter, and the latest elimination, all while balancing the chaos of a two-night premiere. Among the laughter and technical critiques, they spotlight standout performances and evaluate what’s working—and what’s holding some celebs back.

This jam-packed episode examines the women’s performances, from Tatyana Ali’s early fumble and hopeful redemption to Maura Higgins' show-stealing cha-cha with Mark Ballas. Sasha Joseph and Matt compare the energy and nerves between nights, highlighting the troupe’s moment in the spotlight and Derek Hough’s fiery duet with wife Hayley. The discussion also touches on the season’s same-sex pairing with Sarah Jane and Haley, tracing fan support, voting quirks, and representation. Emotional storylines come front and center, especially for Summer House’s Ciara Miller, while wardrobe choices, judge commentary, and the afterparty coverage round out the night's drama and fun.

Dissecting Tatyana Ali’s jittery opener and the struggle to regain momentum after a major slip

Analyzing Maura Higgins’ performance as a surprising early highlight and the chemistry with Mark Ballas

Exploring Ciara Miller’s emotionally charged routine and what it tells us about her state of mind

Comparing judge critiques across the board, including Carrie Ann’s “lift police” moment with Jenna Dewan and Val

Questioning the impact of same-sex pairings and how fan bases shape who makes it through the first eliminations

Reviewing Derek and Hayley’s dynamic ballroom performance and the production’s shift with more elaborate troupe features

Amidst wardrobe debates, fierce competition, and emotional reveals, who is primed to break out in the coming weeks and who’s hanging by a thread in the leaderboard shuffle? Find out how the cast stacks up and the moves that spark the most debate by catching the full episode for your latest dose of Dancing with the Stars insight and analysis.

00:00 Premiere Night 2: Women's Turn06:42 Afterparty Co-Hosts: Dylan and Robert09:16 Derek and Hayley's Powerful Performance13:16 Tatyana Ali's Slip and Recovery18:14 Ciara Miller's Emotional Dedication26:51 Ciara Holds Back, Judges React33:10 Giada De Laurentiis' Struggles Revealed37:34 Julia Stiles' Dolly Tribute Dance43:26 Maura Higgins Stuns Judges51:26 Sarah Jane and Hayley Eliminated56:51 Jenna Dewan Scores With Val01:01:25 Combined Leaderboard, Top Scores01:04:19 Preview: All Couples Next Week

Join the RHAP Dancing with the Stars Facebook group: ?https://www.facebook.com/groups/rhapdwts

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s coverage!LISTEN: Subscribe to the podcast feedWATCH: Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTubeSUPPORT: Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices