Crime in Sports

Superman's Hummer - Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 2

Crime in Sports

Show Notes

This week, we talk more about an NFL player, who never seems to quite "get it". That includes both on the field, where he never lives up to expectations, but even more with his off the field problems. He's again charged with domestic abuse, as he's accused of not only putting his wife's life in danger, but also the babysitter, and his own 2 year old son. This leads to a huge sweep under the rug, from NFL, and being backed by his coach. Will the legal system be so forgiving??

Have one of the best games of your career in the Super Bowl, drive a Hummer at 2 women & a baby, and have Jon Gruden tell everyone what a great guy you are with Michael Pittman Sr. - Part 2!!

Check us out, every Tuesday! We will continue to bring you the biggest idiots in sports history!!

Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman

Donate at... patreon.com/crimeinsports or with paypal.com using our email: [email protected] Get all the CIS, STM & YSO merch at crimeinsports.threadless.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things CIS, STM & YSO!!

Contact us on... instagram.com/smalltownmurder facebook.com/crimeinsports [email protected]

More from Crime in Sports

Oct 13, 2026

This week, we talk about a football player, who started his legel troubles while still in college. His huge biceps became legendary, but so did his constant arrests. He's also on a Super Bowl winning team, making everyone think that all has turned around. The problem is, there was always something under the surface. Either way, he always has an excuse. Even when a cop watched him abuse his girlfriend. Will he be able to keep it together, or will it all come crashing down?

Oct 6, 2026

This week, we look at a basketball player that seemed to have everything that someone could need to be an NBA star. The problem is, he didn't. But he did becaome a criminal, with constant arrests, and even a fake name, once his own name was equivilent to "liar". He stole from teammates, churches, and porn producers, with equal enthusiasm. He led police on a foot chase. Tried to start his own baskeball league, and fed basketball players ramen noodles. This leads to a lot of prison time, and a hilarious story!!

Sep 29, 2026

This week, we look at a muscular woman, who was on the Finnish version of "American Gladiators". She pumped herself full of steroids, leading to some very erratic behavior. She started bar fights with men, causing her to be banned from many establishments. But she also participated in murder, dismemberment, and even cannibalism. Her murder partner described "watching a man's face melt", while cooking it in a frying pan. She is even the main suspect in the disappearence of a 16 year old girl!! Wild stuff!!

Sep 22, 2026

This week, we finish this tale with attitude becoming more important than talent. Kevin continues to be a problem for any team he joins. Despite always putting up good numbers, he bickers, argues, and worst of all, gets arrested, more than the average MLB team will put up with. He even gets in fights on the golf course. He almost loses an eye & is diagnosed with a difficult disease. But there is one story here, that if true, is one of the worst, most vile things an athlete on this show has ever done!!

Sep 15, 2026

This week, we continue the story of a baseball MVP, who can't seem to stay on the same team. His past associations begin to haunt him, when a man who was living at this house, is arrested for the murder of a police officer. But before he could even be traded, he's arrested for a most horrible crime. His attitude becomes a real problem, along with his ballooning weight, which caused one witer to label him "both roly and poly". He also considers quitting the game, but stays. Will his attitude get him run out of baseball??

See all episodes →