
3. There's No One Way to Ranch: Toby Holsted's Story of Leaving the Family Farm and His Path to Profitability
The Ranch Rolodex: Connecting ranchers with resourcesShow Notes
In this episode, Derek sits down with Toby Holsted to share a story that challenges one of agriculture's biggest assumptions: that there's only one path to building a successful ranching business. Toby reflects on growing up on his family's Oklahoma farm, helping build a large stocker cattle operation, and eventually reaching a point where drought, changing markets, and family dynamics forced him to rethink everything. Rather than walking away from ranching, he found a new way forward by questioning long-held paradigms, embracing Ranching for Profit principles, and building a business centered on solving problems for others. The conversation explores the difficult reality of leaving a family operation, the role Toby's wife played in helping him challenge old assumptions, and how Executive Link and Ranching for Profit reshaped both his business and his relationships. Toby also shares how he transitioned from farming and owning equipment to managing custom cattle operations, why proposals and clear communication have become essential to his business, and how finding purpose beyond land ownership has given him the freedom to build a profitable ranching career on his own terms. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with us: Subscribe on YouTube Follow on Instagram @theranchrolodex Follow on Facebook Check out the website
Resources & Links: Ranching For Profit website Scholarship Pledge Scholarship Application Podcast Music by Cade Foehner Check out the Territory Ballroom Sign up for our email list so you never miss an episode
More from The Ranch Rolodex: Connecting ranchers with resources
Access to capital can be one of the biggest barriers to building a ranching business, especially when cattle, equipment, and land all come with a hefty price tag. In this episode, Derek, Zach, and Dan share how they’ve financed their own operations, from conventional loans and FSA financing to private investors and self-financing. They discuss the trade-offs between borrowing money and using your own capital, including how each approach affects growth, risk, and your ability to seize opportunities. They also dig into the importance of building relationships with lenders, managing cash flow, and keeping working capital available for the right deal. Each operation has a different approach, shaped by its goals, resources, and comfort with debt. They also discuss whether more government support is needed to help beginning ranchers access capital and why they ultimately see capital as an even bigger barrier than land. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with us: Subscribe on YouTube Follow on Instagram @theranchrolodex Follow on Facebook Check out the website
Everyone wants to own the dirt they’re ranching on, but what if owning land isn’t always the best way to build a ranching business? In this episode, Derek, Zach, and Dan dig into the tradeoffs between buying and leasing ground, drawing from their own experiences building ranch businesses with limited capital. They discuss how land ownership affects cash flow, why controlling productive land can matter more than owning it, and how the right approach can change as a business grows. The conversation then moves beyond buy versus rent to the relationships that make land access possible. The guys talk about building a strong reputation as an operator, creating win-win arrangements with landowners, and why a rancher’s legacy doesn’t necessarily have to be tied to owning dirt. They also wrestle with when buying land does make sense and why the answer ultimately depends on your capital, stage of business, and goals. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with us: Subscribe on YouTube Follow on Instagram @theranchrolodex Follow on Facebook Check out the website
What happens when a fifth-generation rancher is required to leave the family operation for ten years before he can come back? In this episode of the Ranch Rolodex, Derek sits down with Logan Pribbeno, of Wine Glass Ranch in Southwest Nebraska, a multi-generational ranch that's been in his family for 140 years. Logan's family had a rule: leave the state, leave agriculture, and stay gone for a decade. He spent those years studying economics at UC Santa Barbara and working in Silicon Valley finance through the Great Recession, and he came home viewing the ranch as a business first. Derek and Logan dig into how that time away shaped his approach to ranch finances, from treating cattle as financial instruments to waging war on overhead and using long-term mortgage debt as an inflation hedge. They close on ranch succession, the K-shaped economy, and how Logan structured his operation so he can leave for six months while the business keeps improving. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with Logan: Check out his website Follow on X Follow his podcast, Running on Grass
Everyone says America needs to rebuild the cow herd, but what does it actually take for a rancher to keep back heifers when the market won't give them confidence? In this episode, Zach, Dan, and Derek dig into the cattle market volatility and political noise pressuring producers right now. They look at the latest cattle inventory numbers, why heifer retention isn't the same as herd expansion, and dive into the USDA’s LRP program. The conversation then moves past the headlines to the long-term threats to the U.S. beef supply including urban sprawl, the disappearing tallgrass prairie, generational land transitions, and the barriers beginning ranchers face in accessing land and capital. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with us: Subscribe on YouTube Follow on Instagram @theranchrolodex Follow on Facebook Check out the website
What if the biggest thing holding your ranch back isn’t your resources, your genetics, or your market, but actually not knowing exactly what you’re building toward. In this episode, hosts Derek, Daniel, and Zach sit down with the Vision Flight team to unpack why mission and vision aren’t just corporate buzzwords but essential tools for ranch decision-making, family alignment, and long-term profitability. The conversation walks through real examples of ranchers and families that used the Vision Flight process to move past vague goals and uncover the deeper interests driving those goals. Often finding that clarity changes the entire direction of their business and personal lives. No matter what season of life or ranching you’re in, tune into this episode to learn about the power of a practical framework for turning aspirations into a written plan you can act on. Make sure to hit follow/subscribe so you never miss an episode! Connect with Vision Flight: Check out their website Follow them on Facebook