Locked Up for Nothing: The Truth About Wrongful Convictions
True Crime Catch Up with Adam Lloyd and Stuart BluesShow Notes
Wrongful convictions represent one of the most devastating failures of the justice system, where innocent people lose years, even decades, of their lives for crimes they didn’t commit. In this episode of True Crime Catch Up, we explore how and why wrongful convictions happen in the UK, from police tunnel vision and coerced confessions to failures in forensic evidence and disclosure. Using real cases including Robert Brown, Peter Sullivan, and Andrew Malkinson, we break down the human cost behind the statistics and examine how the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) works to overturn unsafe convictions.
We also dive into the ongoing debate surrounding the conviction of Lucy Letby, asking difficult questions about the role of statistical evidence, expert testimony, and whether complex cases can ever be truly understood by juries. With proposals to limit jury trials in certain circumstances, could the risk of wrongful convictions increase? And how much faith should we place in a system that sometimes gets it so badly wrong? As always, we explore the crime, the law, and the wider implications for the UK, before ending on a lighter note with a brilliant story of a crime-solving dog named Rusty.
Follow True Crime Catch Up on YouTube and social media
Listen to our solo podcasts:
British Murders with Stuart Blues
UK True Crime Podcast Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More from True Crime Catch Up with Adam Lloyd and Stuart Blues
True crime is more popular than ever before. From Netflix documentaries and viral TikTok clips to bestselling podcasts and YouTube channels, millions of people consume crime stories every single day. But as the genre continues to grow, so does an uncomfortable question: when does interest in true crime cross the line? In this episode of True Crime Catch Up, Stuart Blues and Adam Lloyd explore the darker side of modern true crime culture, from serial killer merchandise and murderer fan clubs to the rise of dark tourism and the glamorisation of notorious criminals.
In most murder investigations, detectives are forced to piece together fragments. Circumstantial clues, witness statements, and timelines that don’t quite line up. But sometimes, a case hinges on something far more powerful - a single, undeniable piece of evidence. The kind that leaves no room for doubt. The kind that ends arguments, silences suspects, and changes everything in an instant. This is what investigators call the smoking gun.
In true crime, one thing is almost always expected in a murder story - a body. It tells investigators how someone died, when it happened, and sometimes even who was responsible. But what happens when there is no body, no crime scene, and no physical proof that a murder ever took place? In this episode of True Crime Catch Up, Stuart Blues and Adam Lloyd explore some of the most chilling no body murder cases, where victims vanished without a trace, yet their killers were still brought to justice. From the heartbreaking disappearance of Helen McCourt to multiple high-profile UK cases, this episode dives deep into how convictions are secured without the most crucial piece of evidence.
hat are the biggest and most lucrative heists in UK crime history? In this episode of True Crime Catch Up, Stuart Blues and Adam Lloyd break down the Top 5 most lucrative heists ever carried out in the UK, ranked by today’s value. From the infamous Great Train Robbery of 1963 to the staggering City Bonds robbery of 1990, we explore the planning, execution, and aftermath of these high-stakes crimes. Along the way, we also discuss the Brink’s-Mat gold robbery, the Securitas depot heist, and the Knightsbridge Security Deposit robbery, uncovering how millions - and in some cases, hundreds of millions - were stolen in daring operations that shocked the nation.
Double jeopardy is one of the most important principles in criminal law. The idea that once a person is found not guilty, they cannot be tried again for the same offence. But in the UK, that rule changed. In this episode of True Crime Catch Up, we explore the law of double jeopardy, the Criminal Justice Act 2003, and how advances in forensic science - particularly DNA evidence - have allowed some of the most serious cases to be reopened. From the murder of Julie Hogg to the landmark Stephen Lawrence case, we break down how “new and compelling evidence” can lead to a retrial years after an acquittal.