Certainty4Eternity

I Grew Up Catholic. Here’s Why I Became Protestant | Sam Jensen

Certainty4Eternity

Show Notes

What happens when someone grows up Catholic, discovers Jesus through Scripture, and eventually becomes Protestant?

In this episode of Certainty4Eternity, Sam Jensen shares her story of growing up in an Italian Catholic family, attending Catholic Mass with her grandparents, and first becoming fascinated by Jesus through school Scripture classes.

Sam explains the questions she wrestled with around confession, forgiveness, assurance and the Catholic Church, and how coming to understand salvation through Christ changed her understanding of the gospel.

She also shares what it was like navigating her family's Catholic identity, having difficult conversations with people she loves, and discovering that others in her own family had made a similar journey.

If you've grown up Catholic, are considering leaving the Catholic Church, or simply want to understand why some Catholics become Protestant, this conversation offers a personal and thoughtful perspective.

Timestamps 00:00 Growing Up Catholic 02:03 Discovering Who Jesus Is 05:37 Why Do I Keep Asking for Forgiveness? 08:23 When Your Faith Is Your Family’s Identity 13:14 What Sam Appreciated About Catholicism 14:31 Guilt, Assurance and “Am I Good Enough?” 21:05 Discovering a Family History of Faith 27:42 Leaving Catholicism Without Losing Your Family

Watch, listen and subscribe for more conversations about Catholicism, Christianity, the gospel and following Jesus.

Resources mentioned: 📖 The Road Once Traveled - https://matthiasmedia.com.au/products/road-once-travelled?srsltid=AU7gw4Umm-rj87tPCLx5NjSHv3CNllZeJC_UavyFdlcIraeLDa4W6sB3

💬 Got a question? Leave it in the comments or DM us on socials. We might feature it in an upcoming episode!

📲 Stay Connected 📸 Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/certainty4eternity 📘 Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/people/Certainty4Eternity/61577169852716/

👍🏼 Like this video

🔔 Subscribe for fortnightly episodes

📣 Share with friends curious about Catholicism & Christianity

🔔 If this video raised questions for you about Roman Catholicism or talking with Catholic friends about Jesus, check out Mark's published resources, including "Stepping Out in Faith", a collection of 11 stories from former Catholics. https://matthiasmedia.com.au/search?type=product&q=mark+gilbert

#Catholicism #Protestantism #ChristianTestimony #Gospel #Certainty4Eternity

More from Certainty4Eternity

Oct 15, 2026

In this episode of Certainty4Eternity, Mark Gilbert and Camden Bucey explore the theology of Karl Rahner, the Catholic idea of the “anonymous Christian,” and the way Roman Catholicism understands unity between Catholics, Protestants and the wider world.

Aug 31, 2026

Why are so many young Christians becoming Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox?

Aug 13, 2026

How do you share the gospel with your Catholic friends if you don't fully understand Catholicism yourself?

Jul 18, 2026

Why do Catholics pray to Mary? Why do they use rosary beads? What are relics? Why do Catholics celebrate Ash Wednesday and Lent? And where do these practices come from?

Jun 30, 2026

Many Roman Catholics first encounter the biblical gospel at university. Why?

See all episodes →