Show Notes
What happens when Christians agree on Jesus—but disagree on almost everything else?
After spending several days at Brogrove surrounded by Christian creators, researchers, and conspiracy theorists with wildly different views on everything from Flat Earth and biblical cosmology to Satan's Little Season, technocracy, ancient religions, spiritual warfare, and the supernatural, one thing stood out: people could disagree without losing sight of Jesus Christ.
In this episode of The Berean Files, we unpack what that experience revealed about division in the Christian conspiracy space—and the Church as a whole.
How important are our secondary beliefs? When does a theological disagreement actually become a gospel issue? Can conspiracy research become so central to our worldview that it begins competing with the gospel itself? And what does Scripture say Christians should actually be united around?
We dig into Mark 9, Romans 14, Galatians, Ephesians, 1 Corinthians, 1 John, John 17 and more to get back to the foundation: Jesus Christ crucified and risen, salvation by grace through faith, and a Church called to pursue truth without tearing itself apart over every disputable matter.
We can investigate strange things. We can disagree. We can sharpen one another. We can even change each other's minds.
But the conspiracy isn't the gospel.
Jesus is the center.
Don't take our word for it: "test everything; hold fast what is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21, ESV). Open your Bible, follow Jesus, and email [email protected] with your questions, prayer requests, or stories.
Ad-free listening (on Patreon and Spotify), $5/month with a 7-day free trial: https://www.patreon.com/TheBereanFiles Watch on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@thebereanfiles Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bereanfiles
Until next time, stay Berean.
More from The Berean Files
The headlines feel heavy, and questions about the end times are everywhere. But Jesus didn't call us to panic. He called us to be faithful: to love God with everything we have, to love our neighbor, and to make disciples, teaching others all that He commanded. In this episode, Zack and Jason ask a simple question: if we really are living in the last days, what should change about who we are and how we live today? Growing your own food, raising animals, being ready for hard times? That's great, but it's not the point. The real preparation is walking with God every single day, getting right with the people around us, and letting Him lead our lives. We also talk about the cross that recently fell on a priest and what we should (and shouldn't) read into moments like that. Guest views are their own; Scripture is our final authority.
Do some people really remember past lives, with birthmarks that match how they "died"? Seth Kicklighter, author of Spirit Realm Shenanigans!, is back for part 3 of his series, and he takes on what he calls the best evidence for reincarnation.
Are we building a new Tower of Babel? Zack Killey and Jason Kempf come back to AI, and this one is very different from our first AI episode.
Why do churches carefully guard what’s preached from the pulpit—but give less scrutiny to what’s sung from the stage?
Is the New Age behind Christian conspiracy content?